Our impact
NAAN doesn't provide appropriate adults.
We change the system.
We set the standards, build the evidence, shape the policy, and support the people who deliver the safeguard on the ground - whether they are staff, volunteers, or family members.
Sometimes we lead, sometimes we contribute.
Here are some examples of what has changed as a result.
More effective law and national policy
A new legal definition of vulnerability, based on research evidence
In 2012, police recorded the need for an appropriate adult in just 2.7% of adult detentions. In 2024/25, that figure reached 9.06%; a more than threefold increase, with the steepest rises following the legal changes NAAN helped secure. In some forces, the rate now exceeds 20%.
PACE Code C was fundamentally rewritten in 2018 to include a broader, functional definition of vulnerability; a revised threshold for when the safeguard must apply; new duties on police to actively seek information about potential vulnerability; and confirmation that the safeguard covers voluntary interviews. The Home Office had originally proposed a narrower definition that would have reduced protections; the final version was, in the words of Dehaghani & Bath (Criminal Law Review, 2019), "very different indeed from the Home Office's original proposals."
This chain of events began when the Home Secretary commissioned NAAN to investigate why so few vulnerable adults were receiving the safeguard. Our There to Help report (2015) established the scale of the problem for the first time. The Home Secretary publicly stated: "The status quo is clearly not acceptable." We then shaped the resulting Code changes with Dr Roxanna Dehaghani of Cardiff University, who submitted the collaboration as a REF Impact Case Study: "Improving protections for vulnerable people in police custody."
The gap remains vast; research estimates 20–30% of adults in custody need support. But the direction of change is clear.
17-year-olds recognised and treated as children in police custody
75,000 17-year-olds a year were treated as adults in police custody; denied the right to an appropriate adult and the right to have their parents informed.
That changed in stages: PACE Code C was amended by order of the Home Secretary (2013), and the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015 and Policing and Crime Act 2017 completed the change.
The Earl of Listowel explicitly named NAAN in the House of Lords among the organisations whose contribution made the amendment possible.
NAAN's distinctive role was maintaining the relationship with government from the inside. When the Home Office felt unable to engage with Just for Kids Law (who led the judicial review), they continued engaging with NAAN as a "strategic operational partner."
NAAN's CEO provided a witness statement in the case and appeared on Sky News to build public pressure.
In-person support was protected during Covid-19
NAAN co-ordinated with its members to ensure that AAs continued to attend police custody in-person, throughout the pandemic. This included working with the NPCC and the Home Office to ensure that suitable health and safety measures were taken, that PPE was available, and that AAs were classed as key workers.
In March 2020, a national protocol introduced remote legal representation in police interviews with no safeguards for children or vulnerable adults.
Over three years and five versions of that protocol, NAAN worked to ensure that cases involving children and vulnerable adults were exempted from these cases, so that they continued to be protected by in-person legal advice.
NAAN co-authored Not Remotely with Transform Justice and Fair Trials International. Fair Trials secured a legal opinion from Joel Bennathan QC at Doughty Street Chambers, which concluded the protocol was unlawful. NAAN issued guidance to AA schemes across all five versions, and maintained pressure throughout.
The Policing Minister wrote to NAAN: "Appropriate Adults are a vital part of the criminal justice system and perform a key role in keeping the system going and avoiding miscarriages of justice... you are protecting some of the most vulnerable people in society and ensuring their rights continue to be respected."
The first national police custody risk assessment is being adopted
Police custody risk assessments were designed to identify physical risks like self-harm and suicide; not to assess PACE vulnerability or the need for an appropriate adult.
NAAN proposed a national, evidence-based assessment grounded in psychology, psychiatry and law, bringing together leading academics including Professor Gísli Gudjonsson CBE.
The National Police Chiefs' Council (NPCC) took this forward, has explicitly acknowledged NAAN as the instigator, and invited NAAN to help govern its development.
The framework is now with NPCC 'Chiefs' Council' for approval across all 43 forces.
There is national guidance for police forces on voluntary interviews
The NPCC has published national guidance for all police forces on the conducting of voluntary interviews - full criminal interviews that take place without an arrest and detention.
The NPCC Voluntary Interview Guidance (2024) was co-written with NAAN and other key stakeholders. It includes dedicated sections on appropriate adults, children and vulnerability drafted by NAAN. It is held in the College of Policing Library.
This followed nearly a decade of research and engagement by NAAN, including the first national quantitative study of police use of voluntary interviews and appropriate adult safeguards.
An estimated 145,000 voluntary interviews take place each year, including approximately 27,500 involving children. Adults were recorded as needing an appropriate adult in just 4.8% of voluntary interviews (compared to 8.7% in custody); a third of forces could not even report their volumes.
While we continue to work with others to reduce the use of custody for children and vulnerable people, it was NAAN that noticed that the same safeguards were not being applied to voluntary interviews.
Strip search is under greater and better informed scrutiny
NAAN's 2022 report Police searches of people was a direct response to the Child Q case, in which a Black girl was strip searched at school while menstruating and during a mock exam.
The report was produced without specific funding because we recognised the racial justice and gender dimensions of the issue. It documents ethnic disproportionality in strip search, analyses adultification bias, and addresses the position of trans people being searched. The foreword was written by Saqib Deshmukh, a children's rights activist and member of the Child Q Core Review Group..
By 2026, the report had been downloaded over 1,800 times, and cited in seven independent publications, including a peer-reviewed journal article (Ali & Dymond, 2026, Criminology & Criminal Justice), the Children's Legal Centre Wales, the APPG on Children in Police Custody, and the IOPC's national learning recommendations.
NAAN used the report to engage directly in the Home Office's policy development process, and to support other child-focused organisations who lacked specialist knowledge.
The Association of Police and Crime Commissioners formally recognised our work on strip search scrutiny, with NAAN helping to shape questions for PCCs to ask of their local police forces.
Following NAAN's substantial consultation submission, the Home Office has proposed revised PACE Code amendments, which are pending in 2026.
Following the Supreme Court ruling on the meaning of sex in the Equality Act, NAAN developed guidance for appropriate adult schemes with direct input from a trans person who is an appropriate adult, and are supporting the development of local training for wider adoption.
There is wide support for statutory provision of AAs for vulnerable people
Since 1984, police have been required to secure an appropriate adult for vulnerable adults; but no agency has ever been legally responsible for ensuring that appropriate adults are actually available.
With local authority social care cuts biting, the last 15 years saw local scheme collapse like dominoes. Approximately three-quarters of police forces now rely on Police and Crime Commissioners for adult AA provision; by default, not by design.
NAAN has led the case for statutory provision, building from a standing start to a position where every major stakeholder supports the change:
- Chief Constable Ivan Balhatchet (NPCC lead for Custody, 2025): "I strongly support the call for a statutory provision of AAs for vulnerable adults."
- Dame Anne Owers (Chair, ICVA, 2024): "For over 25 years it has been a statutory duty to provide AAs for children. As Chair of ICVA, I urge policymakers to act on NAAN's call to provide the same mandatory protection for vulnerable adults."
- The Home Office (March 2026): "It is absolutely vital that there are functional safeguards in place for this group." Statutory provision "will be explored as part of the new local governance arrangements that will replace Police and Crime Commissioners in 2028."
Scotland resolved this in 2019 by placing a statutory duty on local authorities for both children and adults. Northern Ireland has a scheme commissioned by the Department of Justice.
Appropriate adults are embedded in national policy development
While the Home Office holds policy responsibility for policing, PACE, and appropriate adults, NAAN works across Government - particularly Home Office, Ministry of Justice, and Department of Health.
We hold a seat on the Home Office PACE Strategy Board, contribute to the NPCC Strategic Custody Board and the Ministry of Justice Quality of Advocacy Working Group, and are a founder member of the All Party Parliamentary Group on Children in Police Custody.
We authored the Crown Prosecution Service's legal guidance on appropriate adults at CPS invitation.
We secured a Legal Aid Agency rule change ensuring lawyers called on an AA's request could be guaranteed payment; without it, the provision was unworkable.
We've worked in partnership with NHS England to build the capacity of Liaison & Diversion teams, and secure £500,000 of pathfinder funding for L&D assessments prior to voluntary interviews.
NAAN has been named in Parliament on multiple occasions spanning 20 years, and since 2012 has responded to every significant PACE and custody consultation; our responses have been downloaded over 5,700 times.
Increased accountability and quality infrastructure
Clear and respected national standards define what good look like
Before NAAN, there was no framework for defining, commissioning or assessing appropriate adult provision. NAAN created the National Standards; the only framework of its kind, against which services are now developed, commissioned, inspected and held accountable across England and Wales. No other body develops or maintains them.
First published in 2006, formally approved by the Home Office and Department of Health in 2011, and substantially revised in 2018 with 56 evidence references and input from 17 organisations. The 2018 revision was the first time people with lived experience of police custody (as a child or vulnerable person) were formally paid to shape the standards.
The standards are endorsed by the Youth Justice Board, the Association of Directors of Adult Social Services, and the Association of Police and Crime Commissioners. Their authority has grown: the Ministry of Justice's Standards for Children in the Youth Justice System (2019) now requires every youth offending team management board to ensure provision complies with NAAN's standards.
In 2025/26, 100% of newly published appropriate adult contracts specified compliance. 91% of surveyed members reported using the standards; 90% said they were effective. The standards suite -which includes a National Standards Self Assessment tool, has been downloaded over 9,500 times.
Youth justice inspections now assess appropriate adult provision
From 2025, appropriate adult provision is an explicit element of youth justice service inspections. Previously it was not assessed at all. As one YOT Manager told us: "AA provision was very much at the back of my mind because it was not part of the YOT inspections."
NAAN secured this inclusion through five years of engagement with HM Inspectorate of Probation, working with our trustees with direct youth justice operational experience to develop a practical inspection methodology in line with HMIP resources, and training inspectors.
The combination of ministerially-set standards requiring NAAN's standards compliance, and independent inspection assessing that compliance, creates a chain of accountability for children's appropriate adult provision that did not exist before.
Appropriate adult schemes now have a voice in police inspections
HMICFRS inspections previously relied solely on what police told inspectors about AA provision, which could result in inaccurate or incomplete characterisations of provision. One published report noted that "some services were not supplying AAs in the middle of the night" without reflecting that the provider was not contractually required to do so.
NAAN engaged with HMICFRS, inviting them to meet with our members. This event generated and agreement that the inspectorate would send a proforma to AA schemes before an inspection, giving them a direct voice in the process for the first time.
This improves public transparency and accountability.
National commissioning infrastructure
We provide the national infrastructure that enables effective commissioning of appropriate adult services:
- commissioning guidance
- adaptable specification template
- bespoke advice and support for local areas
- a Dynamic Purchasing System in partnership with publicly-owned purchasing body YPO.
Over 30 contracts have been commissioned through the DPS since its launch.
95% of published tenders in 2025/26 required NAAN membership or training; 80% of specifications (2021–2023) required NAAN standards compliance.
We have directly advised 17 local commissioning projects, ensuring that budgets are used to deliver the best possible outcomes for children and vulnerable people.
Stronger and wider provision

The whole system is better informed, with access to a shared centre of expertise
Over nine years, NAAN has responded to 2,353 queries: from scheme leaders navigating complex legal and operational questions (41%), non-members (24%), prospective AAs (20%), vulnerable people and their families (12%), and commissioners (3%).
More than 110 member organisations across England, Wales and Northern Ireland make up the network. Members report 100% satisfaction with NAAN's advice and support .
These queries range from PACE Code interpretation to counter-terrorism provisions, from strip search protocols to custody record access.
In many cases our intervention resolves a local problem directly. In others, the intelligence feeds into our national policy work; turning frontline experience into evidence for system change.
Documented outcomes include immediate practice changes at a Youth Justice Service, resolution of custody record disputes, and a real-world tragedy on the day NAAN's CEO was at the Home Office PACE Strategy Board that became direct policy evidence. The advice service is the intelligence loop that connects frontline experience to national policy.
Appropriate adult schemes now have access to standardised training
Before NAAN, there was no nationally standardised training for appropriate adults. Each scheme developed its own materials, or had none.
NAAN has maintained and developed national training over a 20-year trajectory, from the first National Training Pack (2006) to the National Training Course (NTC) launched in 2025.
In its first year, 612 AAs were trained via the NTC, more than double our target. An independent evaluation found 90% strongly agreed it improved their development. Experienced AAs with five or more years in the role reported learning things they had never known before.
Police and health staff teams in custody understand vulnerability
NAAN's PACE vulnerability training videos have been adopted by at least 12 police forces and viewed over 2,730 times (61% year-on-year increase in 2025/26). 74% of police officers surveyed said they would apply the appropriate adult safeguard to more or different people after watching . 83% said resulting changes in their practice would lead to more vulnerable people being identified.
The videos were based on a tutor-led seminar developed by NAAN for police officers, custody healthcare, and Liaison and Diversion teams. That slide deck has been downloaded from NAAN's website over 8,740 times. NHS England asked NAAN to deliver the seminar to 90 Liaison and Diversion service leads nationally.
The College of Policing asked NAAN to review its immersive 'Hydra' custody vulnerability training scenarios and, as a result, amended it to promote deeper consideration of AA need.
The proportion of detentions in which police recorded the person as vulnerable and needing the support of an AA has more than tripled between 2012/13 and 2024/25.
Police forces have been prevented from running unlawful AA schemes
When local authority provision has retrenched, police forces have in some cases attempted to set up their own appropriate adult services; a direct conflict with PACE Code C's requirement that AAs be independent of police. NAAN has intervened in each and every case.
In West Yorkshire (2024), a detailed letter from NAAN's Chief Executive stopped the force from implementing an unlawful scheme, redirecting commissioning responsibility to the Combined Authority; which then published a specification explicitly shaped by NAAN's standards.
NAAN is the only body with both the expertise and the relationship with forces to identify and resolve these problems.
London now has universal appropriate adult provision for vulnerable adults
Before 2018, appropriate adult provision for vulnerable adults across London was, in the words of HMICFRS, "generally chaotic." Many boroughs had no service at all.
In the continued absence of a statutory responsibility, NAAN supported the development of a tri-partite funding agreement between MOPAC, NHS England London Region, and individual London councils. Over five years this resulted in provision in 19 boroughs. But where there was no history of provision, councils did not feel able to fund even one-third of the costs. NHS England did not re-affirm its involvement after the five year project.
In 2023, MOPAC partnered with NAAN as a consultant adviser, first to develop an options appraisal, and then to secure funds for a fully MOPAC-funded scheme.
The result: a £5.4 million centralised commission covering every borough; the first universal appropriate adult provision for vulnerable adults at this scale anywhere in England and Wales. Three providers now deliver 24/7 coverage across all 32 boroughs.
The independence of the safeguard is now nationally protected
Policing had increasingly sought to apply police vetting to appropriate adults; a process that was legally inappropriate, threatened the role's independence, and repeatedly excluded people with old or minor criminal records.
In July 2021, the NPCC wrote to all 43 chief constables confirming that police vetting does not apply to appropriate adults and that the role "is, and must remain, entirely independent from policing."
The College of Policing's Authorised Professional Practice (2025) now explicitly names appropriate adults as not requiring police vetting.
NAAN led this: we identified the problem through member intelligence, produced the legal analysis, engaged the NPCC leads, and contributed to successive drafts of the national letter.
A broader and deeper evidence base
Creating the first national dataset on appropriate adults
Before 2015, no national data existed on the need for appropriate adults for vulnerable adults. NAAN created it from scratch through Freedom of Information requests to every police force, eventually achieving a 100% response rate.
Our There to Help series (2015, 2019, 2020) remains the primary evidence source; downloaded approximately 19,500 times, cited in 44+ academic publications, and featured in The Guardian.
Key findings:
- Police five times more likely to identify vulnerability where an organised AA scheme existed (2015).
- Over 200,000 vulnerable adult suspects per year were not recorded as needing an AA (2020).
- Only one in five people identified as vulnerable by NHS Liaison and Diversion services was getting an appropriate adult, despite 69% having a mental illness (2019).
National data collection is now permanent and mandatory
From 2022/23, police forces are required to report appropriate adult data to the Home Office through the Annual Data Requirement. Previously, NAAN relied on FOI requests.
NAAN advocated for this inclusion as the Home Office conducted a competitive formal review process for additional data inclusion.
This is a permanent system-level change: NAAN created the accountability infrastructure that now produces the official statistics on custody, vulnerability, and AA support for both vulnerable people and all children.
Force-by-force variation is now visible and trackable
NAAN's Vulnerability Identification Tracker; the only long-run time series on police identification of vulnerability in adult custody; is a publicly accessible dashboard covering almost six million detentions.
The VIT enables the force-by-force comparisons that drive improvement and expose inconsistency.
In 2024/25, rates ranged from 2.6% (North Yorkshire) to 20.0% (Lincolnshire and Cleveland). Lincolnshire rose from 7.5% to 20.0% in a single year.
This has driven discussion and action within police forces, including between forces with the same IT systems but vastly different AA rates. It has also driven systemic action, including the move towards a national custody risk assessment.
NAAN's research has shaped academic and policy thinking
NAAN is a named institutional partner in an ESRC-funded Doctoral Training Partnership with Cardiff University, with NAAN's Chief Executive co-supervising the PhD.
In 2026, NAAN launched AARC - the Appropriate Adult Research Community; the first dedicated research network for the role; now spanning seven academic institutions.
NAAN own research publications have been downloaded approximately 30,000 times, and cited in 40+ academic publications across criminology, law, social work, health and policing.
Our strip search report has been cited in seven independent publications, including academic journals, the Children's Legal Centre Wales, the APPG on Children in Police Custody, and by the Independent Office for Police Conduct.
The NAAN/Dehaghani collaboration was submitted by Cardiff University as a REF Impact Case Study.
CEO Chris Bath and Dr Dehaghani co-authored a peer-reviewed paper in the Criminal Law Review (2019) and a Wiley-Blackwell textbook chapter (2025).
Effective Practice Manager Grev Wallington is contributing to a forthcoming academic book edited by Dr Donna Peacock.
Families empowered to support their loved ones
Supporting families who act as appropriate adults
Despite having no public helpline, NAAN has supported around 30 vulnerable people and their family members each year.
Whether it is the parents of autistic children, an adult with a mental health conditions, or families who felt their relative was mistreated, NAAN has responded to every one with care and empathy.
Many appropriate adults are family members or close friends. The law requires police to prioritise parents for children, and they act as AA in the majority of cases.
NAAN's written guides for family AAs have been downloaded over 2,300 times.
Family AAs have access to independent information
NAAN developed an animated video guide for family appropriate adults in partnership with Dr Miranda Bevan (then at the LSE), funded by the ESRC; the first resource of its kind aimed directly at parents arriving at a police station. Over 150 appropriate adults provided feedback on drafts. The subtitles have been translated into seven languages.
The NPCC has disseminated the animation to all force heads of custody. Eight police forces have confirmed adoption. Greater Manchester Police displays NAAN materials in custody facilities. The Metropolitan Police is automating the sending of a link by SMS to parents of children in custody. In Parliament (March 2022), Minister Rachel Maclean described the animation as "groundbreaking" and committed the Home Office to working "to raise its profile through as wide a dissemination as possible."
NAAN worked with the Home Office to develop a "Being an appropriate adult" page on Gov.uk to help family AAs understand their role and find NAAN's video and written resources.
The video has been viewed over 3,500 times.
What others say about our impact
Andrea Brazier
"NAAN has been instrumental in improving our knowledge in relation to all things for appropriate adults. It has supported us in developing our victims standard, helped us shape what we can include and guided us as to how best to include a focus on appropriate adults in our inspection programme."
Sherry Ralph
"We work closely together on many issues covering police custody, and NAAN's resources are invaluable. As organisations we are stronger together and NAAN is a fantastic organisation, dedicated to the effective protection of vulnerable suspects in police custody."
Chief Constable Ivan Balhatchet
"NAAN is a national capability of ongoing importance to policing, providing a high level of impact through a small, specialist function that is not otherwise available to forces."
From our members
"NAAN's support to members is truly invaluable."
“The support is outstanding and even if NAAN don't know the answer they will always find out.”
“I continue to be pleased to be a member. I enjoy every event I have attended... connecting the dots from policy makers to volunteers.”
“NAAN has given me the tools to develop the somewhat haphazard list of volunteers into a trained and supported provision.”
“Being able to contact NAAN by email or phone when I have queries and to get a prompt response makes my role much easier.”