Skip to main content

Non-PACE detentions

NAAN is working to clarify how safeguards for children and vulnerable people apply in police custody when detention is under non-PACE powers.

This includes the role of appropriate adults, the application of PACE Code C, and the need for clearer national guidance.

The issue

Not all detentions are for criminal investigations

Police custody is regularly used for detentions that are not part of a standard PACE criminal investigation. These include (for example) some Bail Act matters, Mental Health Act detentions, extradition-related detentions, prison-related detentions, and other routes into police custody.

This creates a serious and under-examined safeguarding question: When a child or vulnerable person is in police custody under a non-PACE power, does the appropriate adult safeguard apply? And if so, how?

Why this matters

PACE Code C is clear in some places, but ambiguous in others when it comes to non-PACE detentions. Your reading of the Code can lead in different directions depending on which provisions you focus on.

That ambiguity matters because the consequences are significant:

  • If appropriate adults are not required, there may be major gaps in protection for children and vulnerable people in police custody.
  • If appropriate adults are required more widely, police forces and AA schemes may face substantial demand, with implications for commissioning, availability and guidance.

In short: this is not just a technical legal issue. It is a frontline safeguarding, policy and capacity issue.

Our position

The current position

NAAN’s view is that this is an area where national clarification is needed.

There are strong arguments that key custody safeguards apply broadly to people in police custody, even where the detention power is not a standard PACE investigative detention.

At the same time, parts of Code C are clearly drafted around suspects, interviews and criminal investigation processes, which creates uncertainty in practice.

There is also very limited national data on current practice, although available indications suggest that practice is variable between forces and custody settings.

We have prepared a short policy paper for the Home Office setting out the issue in more detail, including legal analysis and practical implications.

Why NAAN has raised this

Appropriate adults are a core safeguard for:

  • protecting rights and entitlements

  • supporting communication and participation

  • helping ensure fair treatment in custody

Where custody is used outside the standard PACE pathway, these needs do not disappear. In some cases, they may become less visible — and therefore easier to miss.

Our paper sets out:

  • the scale and relevance of non-PACE detentions in police custody

  • how PACE Code C appears to apply (and where the ambiguity lies)

  • why the AA safeguard question is not straightforward

  • the policy and operational implications of different interpretations

  • why clearer guidance is needed for police, AA services and commissioners

Next steps

What needs to happen next

This issue needs a clearer national response.

At a minimum, police forces, custody leaders, commissioners and AA schemes need clearer guidance on:

  • when and how AA safeguards apply in non-PACE detentions

  • which Code C protections should be treated as minimum standards

  • what this means for local AA service capacity and commissioning

NAAN will continue to raise this issue in policy discussions and support members to identify and document practice issues where they arise.