The need
Children and vulnerable people are detained, questioned and strip searched by police in an adversarial setting that was not designed for them.
Decisions about liberty, criminal records, and sometimes life itself are made under pressure, often late at night, and sometimes over many hours.
The police must involve an appropriate adult for these two groups. But laws do not automatically translate into reality. Whether protections work in practice depends on the people who deliver it, the systems that support them, and the resources behind both.
The context
1. Police contact is a moment of crisis, unfolding in a high-risk adversarial environment
Police detention and questioning are not neutral environments. They are adversarial settings which were not designed for children or vulnerable people.
They are periods of high jeopardy and risk in people's lives - places where decisions about liberty, criminal records, and sometimes life itself are made under pressure, often late at night, and sometimes over many hours.
The UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child both establish that disabled people and children should be able to participate in the institutions that affect them, including as suspects in a criminal investigation.
International obligations and national laws may create procedural safeguards, but they do not automatically translate into reality. Whether the safeguard works in practice depends on the people who deliver it, the systems that support them, and the resources behind both.
2. Appropriate adults have the potential to protect children and vulnerable people
When police detain, question, or strip search a child or a person who may be vulnerable, the law requires someone independent to be there.
The appropriate adult exists because the justice system, like any mainstream system, must be designed to include the people who use it.
The appropriate adult is what makes that participation possible. It does not remove someone from the process; it makes the process accessible to them.
That person, the appropriate adult, exists to safeguard rights and welfare, support communication, and ensure the person can participate effectively in a process that can shape the rest of their life.
This includes the right not to be detained at all unless detention is necessary and proportionate.
3. Our vision
Our vision is that every child and vulnerable adult detained or questioned as a suspect is treated fairly, with respect for their physical and mental welfare, can exercise their legal rights and entitlements, and can participate effectively.
4. Current reality falls short of our vision.
The National Appropriate Adult Network (NAAN) exists to close the gap: strengthening local provision, informing the people who need this safeguard, and working with others to make the system fairer.
On this page, we set out the challenges and needs of each of the groups that benefit from the work of the National Appropriate Adult Network.
The scale
1. Over a million encounters, every year
Every year in England and Wales, around 930,000 people are detained in police custody, at least 73,000 more attend voluntary interviews, and in 2025/26, there were 586,591 stop and searches. Together, that is well over a million encounters in which the appropriate adult safeguard could apply.
Children
In 2024/25 there were almost 59,000 detentions of children in police custody in England and Wales, and every one required an appropriate adult. Around 43% of detained children were held overnight. Police recorded over 3,300 strip searches of children in custody; a quarter of those children were Black, around four times their share of the child population.
A further 13,500 voluntary interviews of children were recorded, from only 31 of the 43 police forces.
In 2025/26, there were over 100,000 stop and searches of children aged 10 to 17. Nearly 300 of those involved a full strip search exposing intimate parts, which requires an appropriate adult.
Vulnerable adults
Among adults, research estimates that 20–40% of people in police custody have a mental health condition, learning disability, or other vulnerability that should trigger the appropriate adult safeguard. Yet in 2024/25, police recorded only 9% of adult detentions as requiring an appropriate adult. The rate varied tenfold between forces, from 2.6% to 20%. An estimated 160,000 or more encounters with vulnerable adults take place each year without the appropriate adult the law requires.
2. Deaths in police custody
Nearly half of people who have died in or following police custody had identified mental health concerns. Our research indicates that most did not have the support of an appropriate adult.
The independent Angiolini Review into deaths and serious incidents in police custody found that appropriate adults can reduce the risk of self-harm and death, but that provision was too variable and too limited to do so consistently.
As Home Secretary, Theresa May described the situation:
"Appropriate adults provide vital support and help to demystify what can be a confusing, sometimes frightening, experience in police custody. The status quo is clearly not acceptable… the priority must be to act to ensure that vulnerable people are provided with the support they are entitled to."
The people at risk
When the system works
When the system works a child or vulnerable adult in police custody has someone by their side who understands the process, can explain what is happening, ensures their rights are respected, and speaks up if something is wrong. They can understand and exercise their own rights, including the right to say nothing. They can communicate what they want and have it heard. They are not left alone for hours in a cell. They use their fundamental right to legal advice because they understand its long-term benefits and are not put off by misinformation, time pressures, or fears.
When the system fails
When the system fails, the consequences can be devastating: miscarriages of justice, criminal records that follow people for life, deterioration of welfare, and in the worst cases, self-harm and suicide.
Children
Illustrations by Johanna Falkenhagen. Orginally commissioned by Dr Miranda Bevan.

Legal advice barriers

Overwhelm

Fear & bravado

Complexity & acquiescence

Traumatic environment

Long detention times

Feeling alone

Pressure
1. Children: The most vulnerable of the vulnerable
HM Inspectorate of Probation has described children in police detention as "the most vulnerable of the vulnerable and least able to represent their own interests." Research by the Children's Commissioner found that on average, police waited 7.7 hours after a child's arrest before even requesting an appropriate adult. Children spent the vast majority of their time in custody alone in a cell, without any independent adult support. In 2025/26, where forces recorded the information, no appropriate adult was present in around one in six stop and search searches that expoosed the intimate body parts of a child.
2. The pains of child detention
What children describe about time spent in police custody is stark: powerlessness, indignity, isolation, frustration, confusion, humiliation and fear, though they may conceal these feelings from police with bravado.
Children who are questioned or searched as suspects (whether detained in police custody, attending a voluntary interview, or being searched under stop and search powers) need someone to protect their rights, safeguard their welfare, and help them participate in a process they may not understand.
3. Compounded intersectional disadvantage
The average human brain takes 25 years to develop. Yet at ten years old, a child in England and Wales is criminally responsible and may be required to make critical decisions, including whether to have legal advice.
Children in the justice system are not a representative cross-section: they are far more likely than other children to have a learning disability (up to 32%, compared to 4% in the general population), a communication disorder (up to 90%, compared to 7%), to be autistic (15%, compared to 1%), or to have suffered a significant head injury (18%, compared to 5%).
Race, gender, abuse, neglect, trauma, school exclusion, and care experience compound these disadvantages. Much of this is invisible unless actively looked for. A child who appears to "know the ropes" may still be profoundly distressed and disadvantaged.
4. Life-threatening risk
The stakes are not abstract.
The independent Angiolini Review into deaths and serious incidents in police custody documented three cases that changed the law. Edward Thornber hanged himself in a park after being detained and given a warning for possession of a small amount of cannabis; he was later mistakenly sent a court summons, which was found near his body. Joe Lawton was arrested for drink driving and kept overnight in a police station; he took his own life two days later. Kesia Leatherbarrow was held in custody over a weekend and taken to court on Monday; she was not seen by her family again. All three were 17 years old.
Because 17-year-olds were not then treated as children in custody, none was entitled to an appropriate adult and none had their parents informed of their arrest. The law has since been changed, but only after these deaths demonstrated, at the highest cost, what happens when the safeguard is absent.
Vulnerable people
1. Vulnerability is contextual
In this context 'vulnerability' is about the risks generated by a system that was not designed for everyone.
The law requires police to apply a functional test. A person of any age is vulnerable if there is reason to suspect they may:
- not understand or be able to exercise their rights and entitlements
- have difficulty understanding the implications of procedures and processes
- have difficulty understanding or the significance of what they are told, of questions they are asked or of their replies
- be highly suggestible or eager to please
- become confused.
In practice, some of the most common factors are:
- mental illness
- learning disabilities
- brain injury
- neurodivergence (e.g. autism, ADHD)
Due to high prevalance of conditions amongst children in conflict with the law, many should still be receiving support as they become young adults.
2. The pains of detention
What vulnerable adults experience in custody is often deeply distressing.
Research consistently finds that people report not understanding what was happening to them or why, being uncertain about what to say or do, and feeling alone with no one to turn to for support.
Vulnerability is frequently invisible or misread: symptoms of mental illness can be interpreted as aggression or non-compliance, leading to restraint rather than support.
Conditions may not be immediately apparent to officers, and without an appropriate adult to advocate, the person may not be able to articulate their own needs.
These experiences can be compounded by gender. Police custody is an environment culturally and materially designed around adult men; from the physical layout of cells, to the staffing, to the assumptions embedded in risk assessment. Women and girls can be left exposed to particular harms: the indignity of managing menstruation without privacy or adequate facilities, or the risk that trauma histories linked to abuse are retriggered by the custody environment itself. Women in custody are recorded as vulnerable at higher rates than men, meaning the appropriate adult safeguard is disproportionately important to women as a group.
The Angiolini Review into deaths and serious incidents in police custody documented cases where officers perceived distressed or mentally unwell detainees as deliberately non-compliant or dangerous, with fatal consequences.
3. Nobody is responsible for ensuring support
The causes of this systemic failure are the 40 year absence of a statutory duty, diminishing funding, and a lack of clarity over who is responsible.
For children, the answer is clear: local authorities have a statutory duty under the Crime and Disorder Act 1998. For vulnerable adults, there is no equivalent duty; no agency in England and Wales is legally responsible for making sure those protections are available.
Local authorities have increasingly withdrawn appropriate adult services for vulnerable adults, citing financial pressures and the non-statutory nature of the provision. Approximately three-quarters of police force areas now rely on Police and Crime Commissioner funding for vulnerable adult AA provision, an arrangement that raises serious concerns about the independence of a safeguard that is supposed to be independent of policing, and one that is now further threatened by the planned abolition of PCCs.
As Professor the Lord Patel, former Chair of Social Work England and the Mental Health Act Commission, has observed: the non-statutory nature of the provision means that areas with a service are defenceless in the face of budget cuts, and vulnerable adults slip through the cracks between agency responsibilities.
4. Many (most) vulnerable people don't get support
NAAN's There to Help research series, downloaded over 19,500 times and cited in more than 44 academic publications, has found that an estimated 160,000 or more adult detentions and voluntary interviews of vulnerable people take place every year without an appropriate adult, even though one is required by law.
The force-by-force variation in identification rates is stark: in 2024/25, rates ranged from 2.6% to 20%.
Police are half as likely to record that a suspect is vulnerable in areas where no organised appropriate adult provision exists.
That difference reflects how the system operates, not the needs of the population.
The people asked to protect
When the system works
When the system works, every person asked to act as an appropriate adult (whether a parent arriving at a custody suite for the first time, a support worker accompanying a client, or a trained volunteer on their hundredth call-out) has the knowledge, confidence, and support to do the role effectively. They understand what is happening, know what they can and should do, and are equipped to speak up.
When the system fails
The reality is that many people are asked to fulfil this critical role with little or no preparation, in circumstances that are stressful, unfamiliar, and sometimes frightening.
When the system fails, the consequences can be devastating: miscarriages of justice, criminal records that follow people for life, deterioration of welfare, and in the worst cases, self-harm and suicide.
Parents, family and friends
1. Asked to protect, without preparation
When a child is arrested, the police will usually contact a parent or family member first. They are asked to come to the police station, often without warning and in the middle of the night, and act as the child's appropriate adult. Most have never been in a custody suite before. They receive no training, little information about what the role involves, and must navigate a complex legal process while managing their own fear and distress.
2. A complex role with no training or guidance
The law gives parents priority as appropriate adults for good reason: children value having someone familiar and trusted. But the role requires far more than simply being present. An appropriate adult must understand PACE, know the child's rights, facilitate communication with police and lawyers, observe whether procedures are being followed, and intervene if they are not. Research has found that parents frequently do not understand what they are supposed to do, and that some feel powerless in the face of police authority.
3. In their own words
As one parent told researchers: "I feel like I really let [my son] down with not knowing."
Another described the experience: "You've just gotta go along with 'em cos it's the police innit."
4. When support isn't available, outcomes suffer
NAAN's theory of change identifies this problem directly: parents, family and professionals asked to be an appropriate adult are often unaware of the specific responsibilities and powers of the role, and this can create risks in excess of having no appropriate adult at all. An inappropriate intervention in an interview, a failure to secure legal advice, or a misunderstanding of the right to silence can have lasting consequences.
Professional and community workers
1. Trusted relationships, unfamiliar territory
Residential care staff, supported living workers, key workers in charities, youth workers, and social workers may be called upon to act as appropriate adult for someone they already support. For children, this group has the same legal standing as family in the PACE priority order. For vulnerable adults, they are often the first people police contact.
2. A different legal framework, with no preparation
These professionals bring an important advantage: they know the person. They understand their communication needs, their triggers, their history. But they do not necessarily understand the specific legal role of the appropriate adult in custody, which is distinct from their usual professional duties. A support worker who is excellent at advocacy in a hospital setting may not know how to intervene in a police interview, or understand the significance of the caution, or recognise when a strip search procedure is not being followed correctly.
3. Standing alone in an unfamiliar system
The custody environment is also unfamiliar. The power dynamics are different. The legal framework is PACE, not the Care Act or the Mental Health Act. Without preparation, even experienced professionals can find themselves unsure of what they should do, and uncertain whether they have the standing to challenge police decisions.
Appropriate adult practitioners
1. A demanding role in a high-stakes environment
2. Training, guidance and community are crtiical
But they can only be effective if they are properly trained, have access to reliable and up-to-date guidance, and are part of a professional community that supports their development. The PACE Codes of Practice are large, complex, and not structured with appropriate adults in mind. Relevant law, case law, and operational guidance changes regularly. Many practitioners are the only person in their organisation with specialist knowledge of the role, with no colleague to turn to when a difficult situation arises at 3am.
3. Without national infrastructure, every area starts from scratch
Without a national infrastructure providing standardised training, practice guidance, a practitioner knowledgebase, and a professional network, every local area is left to reinvent the wheel. The result is inconsistency in the quality of the safeguard, which is the very thing that children and vulnerable adults cannot afford.
The system that has to make it work
When the system works
When the system works, every area has appropriate adult provision that is consistently available, sustainably funded, quality-assured against national standards, and accountable to the people it serves. Commissioners and providers have the evidence, tools, and support they need to design and deliver effective services. Police understand the role, identify vulnerability accurately, and work constructively with appropriate adults. Effective appropriate adults also benefit the wider justice system: by enabling the fair and lawful investigation of children and vulnerable people, they reduce the risk of failed prosecutions, unreliable evidence, and miscarriages of justice. These are outcomes that matter to police, the Crown Prosecution Service, courts, victims, and the public.
When the system fails
The reality is a patchwork. Provision varies enormously between areas. Funding is insecure. There is no statutory duty for vulnerable adults. And the people responsible for making the system work (scheme leaders, commissioners, and police) are often doing so with limited resources and limited specialist support.
Appropriate adult scheme leaders and managers
1. Specialist work, often without specialist support
The people who run organised appropriate adult provision (within youth justice services, charities, local authority teams, or contracted providers) are responsible for recruitment, training, quality assurance, operational management, and partnerships with police and other agencies. Many do this with very small teams. Some have only a few hours a week dedicated to appropriate adult work alongside other responsibilities.
2. Isolated without a national network
They need operational guidance, quality frameworks, peer support, and access to specialist advice on complex cases and legal questions. The specialist nature of the work means they are often isolated as the only person in their organisation who understands this area of law and practice. When a custody officer calls at midnight with an unusual situation, there is rarely anyone internally to consult.
Service developers and commissioners
1. Commissioning decisions that shape whether the safeguard is available
Youth justice services designing or redesigning their approach. Police and Crime Commissioners deciding how to fund adult provision. Local authorities considering their responsibilities. Combined authorities exploring regional models. All are making decisions that directly affect whether children and vulnerable adults get the protection they are entitled to.
They need clear standards against which to commission, specification templates, benchmarking data, evidence of what works, and access to specialist consultancy. Without these, commissioning decisions are made in the dark, leading to specifications that are too narrow, contracts that do not reflect the realities of the role, and services that cannot deliver what PACE requires.
2. What's possible with the right evidence and support
The London experience illustrates both what is possible and why national infrastructure matters. When the Mayor's Office for Policing and Crime commissioned the first pan-London appropriate adult service for vulnerable adults (a £5.4 million investment covering all 32 boroughs plus the City of London, 24 hours a day, 365 days a year), NAAN provided the evidence base, the quality standards, and the commissioning expertise. But it took a major strategic authority stepping in with direct commissioning to achieve what the voluntary, non-statutory approach had failed to deliver in decades.
Police and other professionals
1. If vulnerability isn't identified, no one is called
Custody officers, investigators, healthcare professionals, and Liaison and Diversion staff are responsible for identifying vulnerability, requesting an appropriate adult, and enabling the role to function effectively. They are the gatekeepers of the safeguard: if vulnerability is not identified, no appropriate adult is called.
2. Recognising needs that are not immediately visible
They need to understand what vulnerability looks like, including the many forms that are not immediately visible, know when the safeguard applies, and be able to work constructively with appropriate adults when they arrive. This requires training, operational guidance, and a culture that treats the appropriate adult as a partner in ensuring fair and effective justice, not as an obstacle to getting through the workload.
3. Variation driven by system design, not officer commitment
NAAN's research has consistently found that the quality of identification varies enormously between forces and is influenced by local interpretation of PACE, the tools officers use, the availability of appropriate adult services, and the extent of training. Where police have access to structured vulnerability assessment tools and work alongside well-resourced appropriate adult schemes, identification rates rise and the safeguard works as intended.
4. Fair investigations need consistent support
Chief Constable Ivan Balhatchet, the NPCC's national lead for custody, has described the problem from the policing side: appropriate adults play a crucial role in the effective operation of not only custody but the criminal justice system as a whole, ensuring that any product of the custody process stands up to scrutiny in court. The absence of a statutory duty for vulnerable adults, he has said, has created an inconsistent and inadequate provision for some of the most vulnerable members of our society and a significant challenge for policing to comply with the law.
What you can do now
If you need an appropriate adult
If you need an appropriate adult (for yourself, your child, or someone you support) you can find out about the role, how to act as an AA for a loved one, how AAs are found, who provides them in your area, and how to make a complaint if support wasn't provided.
If you lead or commission a service
If you run or commission appropriate adult provision and want to improve your service, strengthen your standards, or connect with a national network of practitioners and commissioners, find out about NAAN membership.
If your team needs training
If your team needs training, on understanding vulnerability or the appropriate adult role, explore our online and tutor-led training services and complete our enquiry form.
If you can help to fund our work
If you fund work that supports children or vulnerable people in the justice system and want to understand more about how NAAN works and what your support could achieve, contact us to discuss how we can work together.
- 930,000 detained / 73,000+ voluntary interviews: Home Office PP&P 2024/25 (custody tables D_01; voluntary attendance VA_01)
- 58,000 children arrested: Home Office PP&P 2024/25 arrests table A_01b
- 60,000+ children detained: Home Office PP&P 2024/25 custody table D_01
- 43% children detained overnight: Home Office PP&P 2024/25 table D_09a
- 3,300+ children strip searched: Home Office PP&P 2024/25 table SS_02
- 20–40% mental health prevalence: Angiolini Review (2017), citing police estimates to Home Affairs Committee and McKinnon & Grubin (2013)
- 9% recorded as needing AA / 2.6%–20% force variation: Home Office PP&P statistics / VIT, 2024/25
- Nearly half of deaths with mental health concerns: Angiolini Review (2017), five-year figure 2010/11–2015/16
- Home Secretary quote: Theresa May (2015), cited in NAAN meeting notes for Angiolini Review and in the Review itself
- Brain development to age 25: widely cited in developmental psychology; IOPC Learning the Lessons
- Learning disability 32% vs 4%, communication disorder 90% vs 7%, autism 15% vs 1%, head injury 18% vs 5%: IOPC Learning the Lessons (Chris Bath article, 2020)
- HMIP quote ("most vulnerable of the vulnerable"): Children's Commissioner A Night in the Cells (2017), citing HMIP 2011
- 7.7 hours before AA requested: Children's Commissioner A Night in the Cells (2017) — mean delay from arrest to referral, excluding outliers
- 160,000+ vulnerable adult detentions/VIs without AA: There to Help 3 (2020) — "159,718" at 22% prevalence assumption
- 19,500+ downloads of There to Help series: website downloads analysis
- Police half as likely to record vulnerability where no provision: There to Help (2015)
- Three-quarters of forces rely on PCC funding: NAAN letter to Policing Minister, November 2025
- Familial AA quotes: APPG evidence session, July 2023
- Women recorded as vulnerable at higher rates than men (16% vs 12%): Home Office PP&P 2024/25 custody table D_03b
- Police custody as a gendered space: Skinns, Smyth, Weir, Dehaghani, Hodgson, Munro & Sorsby (2026), Centre for Criminological Research, University of Sheffield, Occasional Paper 13