Vulnerability Identification Tracker
Police are required to secure an appropriate adult whenever they have reason to suspect that a person may be vulnerable.
Studies indicate that 39% of adult detentions are of people with a mental illness or learning disability. The tracker indicates that many vunerable people are not being identified as needing an appropriate adult.
The Tracker
The Vulnerability Identification Tracker (VIT) is part of our identifying vulnerability work, and grew out of our There to Help research series. We want to help improve the identification and recording of 'PACE vulnerability', and the application of appropriate adults for vulnerable adults.
The VIT uses police data to show the percentage of adult detentions in which police called an appropriate adult. Where our research reports reflect what was known at the time, the VIT uses the best available data.
The Tracker:
- can take a few seconds to load
- is best used on a laptop or desktop
- is subject to change based on new data
- is updated annually using national statistics.
The Vulnerability Identification Tracker was created free by digital transformation company UBDS. They didn't ask us to put this hyperlinked logo here. So we have. Our particular thanks to Andy Wakefield, Head of Business Intelligence.
Latest updates
1. Updated data
- Added data for 2024/25 from the official Home Office police custody statistics.
- Replaced Warwickshire’s monthly data for 2021/22 to 2023/24, previously obtained through FOI, with annual data provided by Warwickshire OPCC, on the basis that it is more accurate. Home Office ADR data was retained for 2024/25.
- The VIT is now based on almost 6 million detentions in England and Wales since 2017/18.
- Benefit: Latest data now available
2. Accessibility improvements
- Moved the England and Wales average tracker to the first page.
- Simplified chart titles to make each chart easier to understand.
- Added legends and instructions to improve ease of use.
- Replaced the retired geographical mapping system with more accessible colour coding to show lower rates, higher rates, and missing data.
- Improved the accuracy of annual volume figures by avoiding month-level rounding before annual totals are aggregated for detentions and AAs.
- Benefit: Easier to use and more accurate.
3. Data quality
- The VIT is now based on almost 6 million detentions in England and Wales since 2017/18.
- Only two forces provided no data in 2024/25, compared with six in 2023/24 and ten in 2022/23. This returns data completeness to a level similar to that achieved through NAAN’s FOI collection in 2021/22. Durham has not provided this data since 2013/14. Humberside has not provided data to the Home Office since the collection began in 2022/23, although it did provide data to NAAN between 2019/20 and 2022/23.
- All four Welsh forces provided data. Three recorded zero unknowns, while North Wales Police recorded 97% unknowns.
- Of the 39 English forces, 37 provided data. Twenty-six recorded no unknowns. Among the remaining forces, the average unknown rate was over 90%; in NAAN’s analysis these cases are counted as “No AA required”.
- Benefit: Data are more reliable
1. Updated data
- Data added for 2023/24 (from official statistics)
- Data added for 2017/18 (from NAAN FOIs)
- Additional data added for various forces and dates due to forces providing data after we published the relevant There to Help reports.
- Benefit: Latest public data now available
2. Use of financial years now used throughout
- Data is clearly presented by financial year (e.g. 2023/24) rather than calendar year.
- Users can still drill down to monthly detail if needed (limited to NAAN FOI data years 2017/18 to 2022/23).
- Benefit: Reporting now aligns with how police forces now submit data to Home Office.
3. Missing data returns are more visible
- Where a force has not submitted data for a year, the chart shows a break rather than connecting the line.
- Be aware that data points will not always be joined by lines (you will see a “floating dot” where there is no data for either the previous or next year).
- Benefit: Gaps in submissions are transparent and cannot be overlooked.
4. Consistent time range for fair comparison
- The timeline no longer changes depending on which force is selected.
- All forces are shown against the same overall reporting period.
- Benefit: Clearer and fairer comparisons between forces, including in terms of missing data.
5. Clearer national level comparisons
- England & Wales (aggregated), Northern Ireland, and British Transport Police can now be compared.
- Benefit: National level comparisons are now accurate and easier to interpret.
6. England and Wales no longer includes British Transport Police
- BTP has been removed from the main force comparison pages (the first three pages).
- It is now only included alongside national averages on the dedicated comparison page.
- Benefit: More accurate average figures for Home Office territorial forces, while still allowing BTP to be viewed transparently.
7. Easier police force selection
- Users no longer need to hold Ctrl to select multiple forces.
- Search has been added to force selectors.
- Benefit: Simpler and more intuitive filtering.
8. Cleaner, more consistent layout
- Clearer movement between the four pages with a tabbed navigator at the top.
- Navigation buttons and slicers are now aligned across pages.
- The overall structure is clearer and more consistent.
- Benefit: A more professional and user-friendly experience.
Insights
Click below to discover insights generated by the Tracker.
Found an interesting insight of your own? Share it with us at
England & Wales Average
How to view
- Select the England & Wales Average page tab
- Set the period from 01/04/2017 to 01/03/2025
- Select area: England & Wales
Insight
In 2024/25, police recorded calling an AA for 9.05% of adult detentions. After slowing slightly in 2023/24, the rate of change has increased again, . For reference, NAAN also holds data for 2012/13 and 2014/14, when the national average rates were 2.7% and 3.1% respectively. with research showing that 39% of adult detentions involve someone with a mental illness, learning disability or or neurodivergent condition, rates seem set to increase
Ranking & Map
How to view
- Select the National Ranking & Map page tab
- Set the period from 01/04/2024 to 01/03/2025
- Select all police forces
Insight
In 2024/25, the six highest recorded AA rates were in Lincolnshire (up from 16th), Cleveland (no change), Derbyshire (down from 1st), the Metropolitan Police (down from 3rd), Cumbria (no previous Home Office data), and Sussex (down from 4th).
Four forces recorded AA rates of 18% or higher, compared with two in 2023/24.
The lowest recorded rate in 2024/25 was 2.6%, up from 1.9% in 2023/24 and 0.3% in 2022/23.
How to view
- Select the National Ranking & Map page tab
- Select all police forces
- Set the period from 01/04/2023 to 01/03/2024
- Change the period to from 01/04/2024 to 01/03/2025
Insight
In 2023/24, a chain of forces across the south coast of England had AA% rates well above average. Devon and Cornwall, Dorset, Hampshire, and Sussex all had rates above 11% (compared to a national average of 8.66%). Kent sits at the end of the chain, with a rate just above 9%. Another chain of forces, this time with lower rates around or below 5%, runs in a thick belt from Norfolk through Suffolk, Essex and Hertfordshire, down to Surrey and West through Warwickshire Gloucestershire. This links up with North Wales, Dyfed-Powys, West Mercia and Cheshire, all also under 5%. In the North, a chain of forces from Cumbria, through Durham, North Yorkshire and Humberside, were all unable to provide AA data to the Home Office.
In 2024/25, reporting has improved in the North, leaving only two unconnected forces reporting no data. However, the "High South Coast" and Below Average Belt" patterns persist.
It may be that local forces are more likely to share mutual support, resources, or even culture.
How to view
- Select the Volume v Identification page tab
- Set the period from 01/04/2017 to 01/03/2024
- Select the 11 police forces which provided data in all years fomr 2017/18 to 2024/25:
- Avon and Somerset Constabulary
- Cheshire Constabulary
- Dorset Police
- Essex Police
- Gwent Police
- Merseyside Police
- Metropolitan Police Service (MPS)
- North Wales Police
- Northumbria Police
- Surrey Police
- West Mercia Police
- Observe the bar and line chart on the right hand side, showing detention volumes and AA identification rates
Insight
By choosing a sample including only forces that reported in every year, we can conduct a fair comparison of detention volumes.
Between 2017/18 and 2021/22, detention volumes slowly reduced from 299,000 to 271,000. Beyond this, they started to rise again, ending up broadly where they started at 294,000.
In contrast to this shallow V-shape curve, the proportion of detentions recorded as needing an AA first dipped to 6% in 2019/20, before rapidly increasing to a 'new normal' of around 10%.
Vulnerability identification rates first fell as volumes fell, then rose as they continued to fall, and stayed high as volumes have increased.
Since 2021/22, vulnerability identification has strengthened despite growing volume pressures. This is positive, but creates a double demand effect for AA schemes: more detentions overall, combined with a higher proportion requiring an AA. This reinforces the importance of ensuring AA services have sufficient capacity to meet rising need.
Compare Forces (Bar)
How to view
- Select the Compare Forces (Bar) page tab
- Set the period from 01/04/2024 to 01/03/2025.
- However over the chart on the right hand side.
- Scroll up and down using the vertical scroll bar
Insight
Data are available for 2018/19 and 2024/25 for 34 forces. Around 70% of those forces saw some increase over that period. Of these, it increased most significantly in two forces: Linconshire (up 17.3%) and Derbyshire (up 14.8%). A further 6 forces increased their rates by more than 5%.
How to view
- Select the Compare Forces (Bar) page tab
- Set the period from 01/04/2024 to 01/03/2025.
- However over the chart on the right hand side.
- Scroll up and down using the vertical scroll bar
Insight
Between 2018/19 and 2024/25, the recorded AA rate reduced significantly in three forces: Sussex (-11.1%) Cambridgeshire (-5.5%), and Avon & Somerset (-4.9%) .
Sussex's large reduction is slightly misleading. It experienced a very high, but short lived, peak in 2018/19 (the baseline year). After this its rate has ranged from around 11% to 14%, and it has always remained higher than Cambridgeshire and Avon & Somerset.
To see these changes go to the Compare Forces (Line) page, set the start date to 01/04/2017, and select the three forces.
Compare Forces (Line)
How to view
- Select the Compare Forces (Line) page tab
- Set the period from 01/04/2023 to 01/03/2025
- Select Lincolnshire and Dyfed-Powys.
Insight
Between 23/24 and 24/25, the largest increase was in Lincolnshire, where the recorded AA rate rose from 7.5% to 20.0%.
Dyfed-Powys recorded the second-largest increase, rising from historically very low rates (0.2% to 2%) to 9.4% (above the national average).
How to view
- Select the Compare Forces (Line) page tab
- Set the period from 01/04/2023 to 01/03/2025
- Select Avon & Somerset and Staffordshire.
- Then select the Ranking & Map tab
Insight
Between 23/24 and 24/25, the largest fall in recorded AA rates was in Avon and Somerset, where the rate dropped from 8.4% to 2.7%, raising questions about data quality. Staffordshire also saw a marked reduction, falling from its peak of 12.1% in 2023/24 to 7.8% in 2024/25, moving from 6th to 18th in the ranking.
How to view
- Select the Compare Forces (Line) page tab
- Set the period from 01/04/2024 to 01/03/2025
- Select Dyfed-Powys Police, Gwent Police, North Wales Police, and South Wales Police.
Insight
Across Wales, recorded demand for AAs increased by 40% between 2023/24 and 2024/25. This was driven by a 17% rise in detention volumes combined with an increase in the AA rate from 6.4% to 7.6%.
This is much higher than in England where (among the 34 forces with data in both years) recorded demand for AAs increased by 11%, driven by a 4% rise in detention volumes and an increase in the AA rate from 8.8% to 9.5%.
How to view
- Select the Compare Forces (Line) page tab
- Set the period from 01/04/2019 to 01/03/2024
- Select Cleveland Police, Derbyshire Constabulary, and Metropolitan Police Service.
Insight
These forces consistently record some of the highest identification rates nationally. In 2024/25 Cleveland and Derbyshire were effectively at 20%, while the Met remains close below at 18%. Their sustained performance suggests strong identification processes and organisational focus on vulnerability.
How to view
- Select the Compare Forces (Line) page tab
- Set the period from 01/04/2017 to 01/03/2025
- Select Metropolitan Police Service, Greater Manchester Police, and West Midlands Police.
Insight
Amongst the largest forces, the Met has consistently maintained the highest recorded vulnerabilty identification rate; always followed by GMP, then West Mids below.
In 2021/22,West Minds increased its rate, almost converging with GMP, and since then rates within the the two forces have remianed fairly flat at between 4.8% to 6.3%.
In constrast, the Met's rate increased significnatly, including a sharp rise between December 2021 (8.2%) and January 2022 (15.1%). This may relate to the introduction of structured vulnerability assessment approaches, showing how investment in identification processes can make a measurable difference.
How to view
- Select the Compare Forces (Line) page tab
- Set the period from 01/04/2017 to 01/03/2025
- Select Dyfed-Powys Police, Hertfordshire Constabulary, Humberside Police, North Yorkshire Police, Northumbria Police, Warwickshire Police, and West Midlands Police.
Insight
These seven forces have historically recorded low identification rates, around or below 4%. BUt in 2024/25, Dyfed-Powys (9.4%) and Warwickshire (5.8%) broke out of the group.
It is unclear to what extent these low rates (and improvements) reflect data quality issues or differences in identification practice. This highlights why a robust, evidence-based approach to improving vulnerability identification remains an important national priority.
How to view
- Select the Compare Forces (Line) page tab
- Set the period from 01/04/2017 to 01/03/2025
- Select Dyfed-Powys Police, Gwent Police, North Wales Police, and South Wales Police.
Insight
Welsh forces show striking variation. South Wales Police was increasing steadily but has seen a dip in the last two years. North Wales has remained broadly flat at around 4%, but again has taken a dip in 2024/25 and now has the lowest rates in Wales. Dyfed-Powys long had the lowest recorded rates across England and Wales, but saw the second-largest increase of all forces in 2024/25 and now above average. Gwent has remained at the top, fluctuating over time but also experiencing a significant increase in the last year, to remain top in Wales.
How to view
- Select the Compare Forces (Line) page tab
- Set the period from 01/04/2017 to 01/03/2025
- Select Norfolk Constabulary and Suffolk Constabulary.
Insight
These two closely collaborating forces have annual AA rates that match almost perfectly. Both reached levels significantly above average in 2022/23. Then plunged to around half the national average in the following two years. This shows how shared systems and partnerships can produce similar outcomes.
How to view
- Select the Compare Forces (Line) page tab
- Set the period from 01/04/2018 to 01/03/2025
- Select Metropolitan Police Service and City of London Police.
Insight
Between 2018/19 and 2023/24, the rates in the two forces moved like mirror images. The Met historically recorded slightly lower identification rates. That switched in 2021/22 but the two forces remained within 2% of each other. In 2022/23 the Met recorded sharply higher rates (16.5%), while City's rate reduced just as sharply (2.7%).
The figures for 2024/25 break the mirror-image mould with both forces increasing their rate. City has effectively returened to its 2018/19 rate at 9.5%, but an increase in the Met (18.1%) means its rate is still almost twice as high.
Despite operating in the same city, these forces are very different in terms of scale and the types of crime delt with. THis may explain different vulnerability rates, but perhaps not the wide variations over time.
How to view
- Select the Compare Forces (Line) page tab
- Set the period from 01/04/2018 to 01/03/2025.
- In the police force selector, choose Sussex Police only.
- Click anywhere on the chart and use the drill-down button (double down arrows ) that appears in the top right of the chart to switch to monthly data view.
Insight
Sussex recorded the highest identification rate ever seen, averaging around 25% in 2018/19. Monthly data shows the true peak was far higher — almost 40%, with internal figures suggesting it briefly reached around 50%. This reflects a period when appropriate adults were embedded in custody, dramatically increasing identification. When this changed, rates fell sharply and stayed continuously flat. This demonstrates how operational practice can strongly influence identification rates.
Volume v Identification
How to view
- Select the Volume v Identification page tab
- Ensure all police forces are selected
- Set the period from 01/04/2017 to 01/03/2018 and observe the dotted trendline on the scatter chart (left side)
- Then change the period to 01/04/2024 to 01/03/2025 and observe how the trendline has changed
Insight
In 2017/18, there was almost no relationship between detention volume and AA identification rates. Larger and smaller forces recorded broadly similar rates, with no clear pattern.
By 2024/25, a slightly clearer positive relationship has emerged, with larger forces tending to record higher identification rates.
This suggests that higher custody demand does not prevent effective identification of vulnerability. Larger forces may now have stronger processes, training, or access to better funded AA provision, enabling more consistent application of the safeguard at scale.
How to view
- Select the Volume v Identification page tab
- Ensure all police forces are selected
- Set the period from 01/04/2017 to 01/03/2025
- Observe the bar and line chart showing detention volumes and AA identification rates
Insight
Across the 38 forces that provided data in both 2023/24 and 2024/25, recorded demand for AAs increased by 12.5%, from 65,649 to 73,859. This reflected both higher adult detention volumes (up 4.5%) and an increase in the recorded AA rate from 8.7% to 9.3%.
Custody demand has increased significantly, and the proportion of cases where an AA was called has increased even more rapidly.
Identification rates have risen , rather than falling as demand increased. This indicates that vulnerability identification has strengthened despite growing operational pressure.
However, this creates a double demand effect for AA schemes: more detentions overall, combined with a higher proportion requiring an AA. This reinforces the importance of ensuring AA services have sufficient capacity to meet rising need.
How to
Use the navigation tabs at the top of the report to move between the pages:
- England & Wales Average
- National Ranking & Map
- Compare Forces (Line)
- Compare Forces (Bar)
- Volume v Identification
Use the date selector at the top left of the report. You can either:
- Enter your preferred start and end dates; or
- Use the calendar icons to browse to a differnt year, month and day.
Notes:
- The earliest available data are from April 2017. If you set a start date before this, the report will include data from April 2017.
- The latest data currently available are annual totals for 2024/25. If you select an end date of 1st March 2025 or later, all data for 2024/25 will be included.
- By default, data are presented by financial year (April–March). However, for some years, you can 'drill down' to monthly detail (see below for how to drill down).
- There is no day-level data. However, each month's data is registered on the 1st day of the month, so any day in April will include all of the data for the month of April.
- To ensure accurate financial year results, make sure you pick a start date in April and an end date in March.
Click the drop-down box labelled "2. Select police forces(s)".
If you wish to view all the available data:
- Click to tick the "select all" box (this is the default view)
If you wish to view data for a single force:
- Click to untick the "select all" box (this is the default view)
- Start typing the name of the force in the search bar (just above "select all")
- Or scroll down and click to tick the force
If you wish to view data for multiple forces at the same time:
- Click to untick the "select all" box (this is the default view)
- Scroll down and click to tick each force (the report will instantly update as you add forces)
- Click to untick a force if you wish to remove it.
Select page "England & Wales Average"
The default view shows the annual average for all Home Office territorial forces combined.
Click the drop-down box labelled "2. Select area(s)" to compare England & Wales with:
-
Northern Ireland
-
British Transport Police
You can drill down to a monthly level for some time periods (see "How to drill down")
The reports now default to annual data. This is because from the financial year 2023/24 only annual data are available (via Home Office statistics).
Prior to 2023/24, NAAN secured monthly data from forces via the Freedom of Information Act. These monthly data are still available in the report via "drill down".
In years where only annual data are available (2023/24 onwards) the monthly data will show as a flat line. This is because we have averaged the annual totals across 12 months - so this is not accurate at the month level).
Forces have the option to provide us with corrected data. If they provide us with accurate annual totals we use them to replaced erroneous monthly data. Again, we have averaged these across the months.
There are two ways to drill down, depending on what you want to see.
If you want to see the monthly data for a specific year
- Choose the Compare Forces (Line) or England & Wales Average report page
- Select the force(s) you want to see
- Right click on the data point (the node connected by lines) for the year you want to drill down into
- A menu will appear by the data point
- Left click "drill down"
- The x axis will now show each month for the year that you clicked on.
If you want to see all the monthly data for a specific force (or group of forces)
- Choose the Compare Forces (Line) or England & Wales Average report page
- Select the force(s) you want to see
- Left click a blank space on the report (not on a data point)
- A menu will appear in the top right corner of the report (under the NAAN logo and Vulnerability Identification Tracker title) with various arrows.
- Click the double arrows pointing down to drill down to monthly data. The X axis will change to monthly
- The x axis will now show each month for all the years for which there is data
- A scroll bar will appear at the bottom of the screen - move this to the right to see later months.
- Click the single up arrow (first button) to drill back up to annual data.
About the tracker
The Vulnerability Identification Tracker illustrates the extent to which each police force (and all police forces as a whole) apply the appropriate adult safeguard to adult detentions.
It shows the percentage of adult detentions in custody in which the police recorded that they called an appropriate adult.
Subject to the limitations below, here are some of the things you can use the vulnerability identification tracker for:
- identify opportunities for development in your local police force
- see whether identification is changing over time (locally or nationally)
- track the impact of any changes being made (e.g. new training)
- compare multiple police forces in a particular geographical area
- compare multiple police forces that are a similar size
- compare the averages in England and Wales with Northern Ireland.
The tracker has five pages. Use the tabs along the top to move between them. Every page has the same two controls: a period selector and an area or police force selector. Every page also shows three summary figures for whatever you have selected: total adult detentions, total AAs called, and the AA rate (AA%), which is the percentage of adult detentions in which police recorded calling an appropriate adult.
1: England & Wales Average
A line chart of the AA rate for England and Wales as a whole, by financial year. You can add British Transport Police and Northern Ireland to compare them with the England and Wales average. For 2017/18 to 2022/23 you can drill down to monthly data (see "Drill down to monthly data" in the How to guide).
2: Ranking & Map
Two linked views for your chosen period. On the left, police forces are ranked from the highest AA rate to the lowest. Click a force to highlight it on the map. On the right, a map of police force areas is shaded by AA rate: darker blue means a higher rate, and grey means the force provided no data for the selected period. Hover over or click an area to see its rate.
3: Compare Forces (Line)
A line chart showing how the AA rate has changed over time in one or more police forces. Where a force did not provide data for a year, the line is broken rather than joined, so gaps in reporting are visible. As on page 1, you can drill down to monthly data for 2017/18 to 2022/23.
4: Compare Forces (Bar)
Two bar charts. On the left, the AA rate for each selected force in your chosen period. On the right, the change in each force's AA rate since 2018/19, shown in percentage points. Forces with no data for 2018/19 are not included in the right-hand chart. To see the latest change, select the most recent financial year (for example, 01/04/2024 to 01/03/2025).
5: Volume v Identification
Two charts exploring whether the AA rate is related to how busy custody is.
On the left, each dot is one police force in one financial year, plotted by its number of adult detentions and its AA rate. The dotted trendline shows the overall relationship: if it slopes upwards, forces with more detentions tend to record higher AA rates; if it slopes downwards, they tend to record lower rates; if it is flat, there is no clear relationship. If you select a single force, each dot shows that force in a different year.
On the right, bars show total adult detentions and the line shows the AA rate for each financial year. Detentions are only counted for forces that also provided AA data, so this chart does not follow a fixed group of forces over time.
Financial years 2018/19 to 2022/23
Data were provided by police forces to NAAN, in response to requests made under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA). Police force responses are available via WhatDoTheyKnow.com. Data up to March 2019 was previously published in There to Help 3 (2019). Data from April 2019 has not previously been published. 2022/23 was the last year that NAAN collected monthly data via FOI due to the inclusion of annual data in the ADR (see below)
Financial years 2023/24 onwards
Data were provided by police forces to the Home Office as part of the Annual Data Requirement informing the Police powers and procedures England and Wales statistics. These data are annual only (there are no month level data). Reporting on AAs started in 2022/23 however we have preferred the FOI data provided to NAAN in this cross-over year, as this was provided at the monthly level.
Force updates
Where a police force identifies that data provided to NAAN (via FOI) or the Home Office (via the ADR) was poor, and can provide higher quality data, this will be used instead even if it requires the use of annual data over monthly data. See "What are the data limitations" below.
No data on children
The VIT does not include any data related to children (under 18 years). All children must have an AA by virtue of age.
National statistics indicate that in 2023/24, an appropriate adult was called for 98% of child detentions.
Data relating to AA involvement
The VIT aims to understand the extent to which the AA safeguard is being triggered. In practice, there are several stesp in this chain, including the prevalance of relevant conditions, identification of a person as vulnerable, recognition that this equates to vulnerability as defined by PACE Code C, the calling of an AA, the arrival of an AA, and the recording of the above.
For simplicity, we have sought to focus on whether the police recognised the need to apply the AA safeguard.
Where data were obtained via FOI Act requests, our request was for the "total number of authorised detentions of adult suspects (aged 18 or over) in which the need for an appropriate adult (under PACE Code C) was recorded in that month".
With the switch to official statistics, the Home Office now ask police to report separately on:
- Adults in custody by whether they were considered vulnerable
- Vulnerable adults in custody by whether an appropriate adult was called
We have assumed that the police contacted an AA for all adults for whom they considered there was a need. Therefore we have treated the second figure as equating to the question we asked under the FOI Act.
This means that the VIT does not show the percentage of adult detentions:
- which involved an adult who had some form of vulnerability
- which involved a vulnerable adult as defined by Code C 1.4 and 1.13(d)
- where an appropriate adult arrived
- where police called an AA but did not record this in the custody record.
It is possible that, in some cases, the need for an appropriate adult was recorded but no appropriate adult was secured. It is also possible that in some cases an appropriate adult was secured but this was not recorded. We have assumed that the net effect of any such cases is not material.
Lack of any data for some forces in some periods
Some forces were not able to provide monthly data on adult detentions (detention data) and recorded need for appropriate adults (AA data) for every period.
Lack of AA data for some forces for some periods
Where detention data were available, but AA data were not available, we have not included the detention data. This means that the tracker will not always give accurate detention data.
Lack of month level data for some periods for some forces
During the NAAN FOI period (2017/18 to 2022/23) most forces provided month-level data. However, some forces (e.g. North Yorkshire, Nottinghamshire) were only able to provide annual total figures.
When these data became official national statistics (2022/23 onwards) only annual totals are available for all forces.
Where only annual totals are available, we have averaged the total detentions and appropriate adults across the 12 months of the year. While this remains accurate at the annual level, it is not accurate at the month level. This averaging is clear when the chart is in 'drill down' mode as it it will show as a flat line throughout the year.
Impact of IT systems
Our research indicates that the choice of custody IT systems has a statistically significant effect on the recorded vulnerability identification rate.
Some changes in reported recorded need will be the result of changes in custody IT systems. Such changes can impact the quality of both data recording and reporting. For example, Greater Manchester Police reported very low AA need in April-June 2019 before seeing a significant increase; the forces stated in it's FOI response that "In July 2019, GMP implemented one of the largest IT infrastructure changes in UK policing".
For further information about data limitations, see There to Help 3 (2019) and individual FOIA responses.
Differences between FOI and Official Statistics in 2022/23
2022/23 was a 'crossover' year in which we have both NAAN FOI (monthly) data and Home Office (annual) data.
On comparison, these data do not match up perfectly for all forces.
- Several forces did not supply data to the Home Office despite haivng provided it to NAN under FOI.
- One force (Hampshire) provided data to the Home Office but had not provided it to NAAN
- The total monthly figures provided to NAAN do not all equal the total annual figure provided to the Home Office.
We have generally preferred NAAN FOI data for 2022/23 in order to take advantage of:
- higher number of forces that provided data
- month-level data
- higher totals (which we assume are more accurate).
This generally favoured higher RVIRs (AA%). In most cases differences were less than 2%, although with the national average aorund 8% this is relevatively significant.
Several forces had RVIR rates that were much higher in the NAAN data versus the Home Office data, prompting further analysis:
- Lancashire (11.9% v 4%)
- Northamptonshire (15% v 7.6%)
- West Midlands (4.2% v 0.1%).
In a small number of forces we switched to Home Office data instead in order to increase accuracy:
- Bedfordshire's AA totals in the NAAN data were significantly lower than in the Home Office data, and out of line with previous and future years
- Hampshire provided Home Office annual data but had been unable to provide NAAN with data
- Lancashire provided NAAN with monthly detention totals that were clearly too low (with reference to separate arrest statistics)
Updates from police forces
Where we are informed that data provided to NAAN via FOI or the Home Office via the ADR is significantly inaccurate, we request corrected data from the police force or PCC. If this is available and verifiable, we update the data from the new source.
The following forces have provided revised data:
Warwickshire
Data source: Office of the Police and Crime Commissioner
Data replaced: 2021/22 and 2022/23
Data supplied: 28.04.2026
Notes: The OPCC also provided data for 2023/24 but as this was not supplied for the ADR there were no data to replace.
The tracker can be used on mobile. However, you will
- not have the ability to select multiple police forces
- may find it difficult to see and navigate the tracker
We recommend turning your device to landscape mode, and using a keyboard where possible (so that you can hold down Ctrl/Command)
We recommend using a computer.
Unlike our published reports, the VIT is intended to hold the best available data. If you believe the data are incorrect and better data are available, please email us at
Interested in knowing more ...?
Identifying vulnerability
Every month, thousands of people with additional needs go unidentified when detained or questioned by police in England and Wales.
This means many people, including those with learning disabilities, mental illnesses, and neurodiverse people, do not get the support of an appropriate adult as required by law.
Vulnerable people
We're are not just working on identification. Did you know that while local authorities have a legal duty to provide an appropriate adult for children, there's no equivalent duty to provide one for vulnerable adults?
Click below to find out more, and catch up on our latest activities, updates and media.
About AAs
The role of the appropriate adult is to safeguard the interests, rights, entitlements and welfare of children and vulnerable people who are suspected of a criminal offence, by ensuring that they are treated in a fair and just manner, and are able to participate effectively.
Discover more about the appropriate adult role, and find your local scheme.
