Skip to main content

Children and young people

NAAN is engaged with a range of policy issues affecting children and young people who experience police custody or voluntary interviews. 

We work closely with organisations and individuals involved with children's rights and the criminal justice system.

We are supporting the All Party Parliamentary Group on Children in Police Custody with an inquiry. Read our evidence here. 

Our work

Children's experience

Powerlessness. Indignity. Isolation. Frustration. Confusion. Humiliation. Fear.

These are the feelings children often describe about time spent in police custody, though they may conceal them from police with bravado.

We use our position to highlight the specific needs of children and young people and to safeguard their interests in policy development.

Making rights real

There is a significant, perhaps widening, gap between law and practice. Some PACE requirements are seen as impractical. Breaches are commonplace and often considered a minor matter, especially where cases will not go to court. Resources are critical. Both police and councils are doing difficult jobs in challenging circumstances. However, so is culture. Notwithstanding the police’s rigorous focus on physical safety, and initiatives on modern slavery, trafficking, county lines, and using custody constructively, children are in the first stage of an adversarial justice system. They are in crisis and at risk. They are not ‘safe’.

Collaboration

Much more must be done by all of us: NAAN, government, police, lawyers, councils, providers, and AAs. We must make sure our ‘children first’ laws and policies apply in practice.

We work collaboratively with the Children's Commissioner, Child Rights Alliance for England, HMICFRS, Howard League for Penal Reform, Just for Kids Law, Dr Miranda Bevan, Dr Vicky Kemp, Youth Justice Board. 

NAAN is a member of the Alliance for Youth Justice and APPG on Children in Police Custody.

Appropriate adults

The Police and Criminal Evidence Act (PACE) requires police to involve AAs when detaining, or voluntarily interviewing, any child or ‘vulnerable person’ (defined in Code C 1.13(d)). Without one, proceeding with many processes would breach PACE, risking an unfair investigation and inadmissible evidence.

AAs safeguard a person’s interests, ensuring fair treatment, effective participation, understanding of rights, and the ability to exercise them. They support, advise and assist; observe and intervene; and assist communication. Importantly, they cannot give legal advice but can make sure a lawyer attends, even if a child has declined legal advice. The AA role covers the entire custody episode and can be complex and challenging.

Over use of detention

Minimising detention

Minimising children’s detention is central to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, National Police Chiefs Council strategies on custody and children, and College of Policing Authorised Professional Practice. Yet average detention times have risen. Children are sometimes unnecessarily detained in the day and overnight – a risk for them and police.

NAAN helped to establish the All Party Parliamentary Group on Children in Police Custody, chaired by Janet Daby MP and is an external member. We are supporting a call for a shorter 12-hour PACE clock (detention limit) for children. 

Bail and accommodation transfers

The extent to which police authorisations, reviews of detention and pre and post charge bail decisions are focused on children’s interests is variable. 

The police are less likely than courts to grant bail. 

Councils are failing in their legal duty to provide accommodation and sometimes police do not request it, or request secure accommodation when the legal threshold is not met (see our dedicated page on 
PACE section 38(6) transfers to local authority accommodation).

Appropriate support

Limited access to appropriate adults

The AA safeguard is essential, but too often it is not used effectively. While many children receive rapid, extensive and excellent support, some only get an AA immediately before an interview. They spend hours without support, significantly increasing risks to justice.

PACE requires police to tell the AA and secure their attendance as soon as is practicable, and children have a right to consult privately with their AA at any time. However, research has found police delaying referrals and limiting access to children.

Legislation and standards make it clear council AA provision must be available at any time. Nevertheless, availability is a common frustration.

Despite clear national standards, some schemes are still not able to operate 24/7, respond quickly enough, support the entire custody process, or support voluntary interviews. Councils must design and resource AA schemes that enable PACE compliance. 

Family appropriate adults

PACE prioritises parents as AAs (unless involved in the case), and many children will value someone familiar and trusted who understands them. Yet, in emotional circumstances, parents must interpret PACE, understand their role, and challenge police appropriately, while relying on them for information. Well trained AAs (volunteers or paid) have the knowledge and experience to challenge without obstructing an investigation and, in theory, could be subject to inspection or regulation. But they are usually unknown to the child and must be skilled in building rapport. We've developed resources for family appropriate adults, including a video. And we are encouraging AA schemes to work together with parents.

Interviews and searches

Voluntary interviews

The extent to which police authorisations, reviews of detention and pre and post charge bail decisions are focused on children’s interests is

While addressing concerns about using custody for children, voluntary interviews bring their own risks. In addition to most AA schemes, most liaison and diversion services (which expertly identify vulnerability in custody) are not configured to serve them. With no independent custody officer, investigating officers are responsible for rigorously applying safeguards against themselves. Children (and parental AAs) may see such interviews as informal chats, not deserving of legal advice. See our dedicated policy page on voluntary interviews. 

Strip searches

Whether it is strip searches or intimate searches of children, in police custody or under stop and search, the system of police powers is complex. And the safeguards are more limited than most people realise. 

Our report, prompted by the strip search of Child Q and others, highlights a wide range of issues including ethnic disparities and traumatic impacts, especially on children and vulnerable people. It suggests a range of potential strategic and technical changes, including a new focus on safeguarding.

Vulnerability

Vulnerability

The average human brain takes 25 years to develop. Yet at just ten, a child is criminally responsible and must make key decisions, such as whether or not to have legal advice.

Children in custody are disadvantaged by more than cognitive development. They are much more likely than other children to have poor mental health, a learning disability (up to 32% versus 4%), communication disorder (up to 90% versus 7%), be autistic (15% versus 1%), or have suffered a head injury with loss of consciousness for more than 20 minutes (18% versus 5%). Race, gender, abuse, neglect, trauma, exclusion, and ‘looked after’ status can also compound disadvantage.

Much of this is invisible unless actively looked for. Children detained regularly may be seen to ‘know the ropes’ causing their distress and disadvantage to go unrecognised and unaddressed.

Past issues

17 year olds are children

NAAN was proud to work alongside bereaved parents and other charities to ensure 17 year olds were recognised as children in police custody – and secure their right to an appropriate adult.

By order of the Home Secretary Theresa May, PACE Code C was amended to this effect in 2013. The status of 17 year olds was improved in legislation with the passing of the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015 and fully rectified by the Policing and Crime Act 2017. 

17 year olds make up a very large proportion of all arrested children. Therefore, this very welcome change resulted in a significant increase in demand on children’s appropriate adult schemes, which are a statutory duty of Youth Offending Teams. However, under the new burdens doctrine, the Home Office was expected to fund this increased burden on local authorities. Years later, no such transfer of funds has yet taken place. NAAN repeatedly raised the issue with the Home Office and published a paper estimating the cost to local authorities to be around £1.5 million per year. 

Still interested...?

Policy

Vulnerable people

We're are not just working on identification. Did you know that while local authorities have a legal duty to provide an appropriate adult for children, there's no equivalent duty to provide one for vulnerable adults?

Click below to find out more, and catch up on our latest activities, updates and media.

Policy

Our priorities

We're working on a wide range of policy and practical issues, including:

  • Vulnerable adults
  • Children
  • Voluntary interviews
  • Strip and intimate searches
  • Remote legal advice
  • Accountability 
Information

About AAs

The role of the appropriate adult is to safeguard the interests, rights, entitlements and welfare of children and vulnerable people who are suspected of a criminal offence, by ensuring that they are treated in a fair and just manner, and are able to participate effectively.