Skip to main content

Child First Pilot (Surrey)

An academic evaluation of Surrey Police’s child first custody pilot (referred to by the acronym “CHILD”) highlights the importance and impact of appropriate adults for children. 

Below we share our reflections on the implications of the evaluation for AA provision, and highlight links to key national standards. 

About the report

The CHILD mnemonic

Previously used in the Metropolitan Police Service this approach, which aims to make custody more child-focused and less harmful, has 5 elements.
  • Change the presumption of legal representation
  • Have a conversation with the parent, guardian, and appropriate adult
  • Inform the local authority
  • Limit the PACE clock to 12 hours
  • Direct the investigation without delay.

Key findings

The report is encouraging for AAs. It shows that when police leadership and custody culture focus on children: AAs are brought in earlier; children get better support sooner; AA access becomes more meaningful; AA services are recognised as critical infrastructure; but consistency and resourcing still matter.

  1. The AA scheme is a strength in the system
  2. A 12-hour clock makes AA support more focused
  3. High vulnerability levels justify strong AA safeguards
  4. Early AA contact made a visible difference
  5. Trained AAs were already driving the “presumption of legal advice”
  6. Access to AA support during detention
  7. Policing culture, detention and voluntary interviews
  8. Challenges for AAs around resources and standardisation

    1. The AA scheme is a strength in the system

    The Surrey Appropriate Adult Volunteer Service (SAAVS) comes across very positively:

    • 24/7 cover
    • expectation to attend quickly (aiming for within an hour)
    • willingness to attend overnight (including for rights and samples).
    • attendance not just for interview.

    Custody staff repeatedly praised SAAVS, which is notable because reports often highlight AA delays rather than strong AA practice.

    National Standard 5.2 (Hours of operation)

    Indicator (a): Provision is structured and fully resourced to ensure the availability of an effective AA 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365/6 days a year.

      2. A 12-hour clock makes AA support more focused

      Even though it’s not an AA-specific measure, the 12-hour clock is the report’s standout success:

      • shorter detentions overall
      • fewer very long detentions
      • fewer overnight detentions
      • stronger pressure on investigators to move cases along.

      It clearly increases the effectiveness and efficiency of AAs, with less prolonged waiting and fewer situations where children are left in limbo. This reduces purely custodial AA time, making the AA’s support more meaningful rather than being treated as ‘babysitting’ and distraction during delay. By reducing average detention times, the 12-hour clock increases the proportion of the child’s detention time for which the AA is present. This is a clear example of how AA effectiveness is linked to system design, not just AA behaviour.

      National Standard 5.10 (Scope of support in custody)

      "Children (under 18) and vulnerable persons are supported throughout a detention episode".

        3. High vulnerability levels justify strong AA safeguards

        The report highlights high rates of vulnerability indicators (self-harm, suicidality, child protection issues, etc.) and says these likely understate the true picture (especially in terms of neurodivergence). This strongly supports the need to ensure that both adult and child AA practice must be underpinned by knowledge and skills related to vulnerability. It also highlights opportunities for AAs to work closely with Liaison and Diversion, and for the improvement of real-time information flows with youth justice services and children’s services.

        National Standard 3.9 (Mental vulnerability)

        "AAs are able to recognise the needs of a child or adult who is mentally vulnerable and ensure that they are met".

          4.    Early AA contact made a visible difference

          Researchers felt that Surrey’s custody teams had clearly absorbed the expectation that they should identify and contact the child’s AA/parent as early as possible, often at the point of arrest, not later in the custody process. Staff described this as a major practical shift.

          The report is explicit that this improved children’s experience, with quicker AA attendance, earlier support, and more chance of the child being treated as a child, not just “processed”.

          This is despite AAs reporting long waits for solicitors (up to 2 or 3 hours), and officers echoing this (especially “stacking” multiple cases and refusing to hand them back). AAs recognised lawyers were part of a “system that’s under resourced”.

          It links to any earlier recommendation from the researchersthat Code C should require AAs to attend as soon as possible and physically meet the child within one hour of request.

          National Standard 5.3 (Response times)

          "Children and vulnerable persons receive AA support with the shortest possible delay. Indicator (b): In case of arrest and detention, AAs arrive as soon as possible after the police request is made, normally within one hour and always within two hours (schemes are not responsible for any delay in a request being made by police)".

          National Standard 6.4 (Securing legal representation)

          "AAs ensure that a legal representative is requested for the person they are supporting (in custody or voluntary interview) whenever it is in that person’s best interests".

            6. Access to AA support during detention

            Surrey often allows children to sit out with their AA (especially parents/family) in consultation rooms while waiting, reducing time isolated in cells. Staff linked this to reduced distress and risk.  This was embedded in the CHILD approach to the point that officers said they now have to justify putting a child in a cell on the checklist - a meaningful cultural change.  However, the report also notes barriers:

            • too few consultation rooms
            • busy suites
            • “sit out” practice is less commonly expected when the AA is a SAAVS volunteer rather than a family member/social worker (creating a two tier experience)
            • sometimes children don’t want to sit for hours with an unfamiliar volunteer AA.

            Where AAs were not a continuous presence, researchers felt that Surrey’s approach to enabling children to speak privately to their AA by phone was better than what previous research found elsewhere. Some staff described it as straightforward to arrange a private call. But practice still varied across suites, and one officer indicated “at any time” access wasn’t routine in their suite. So Surrey is not fully consistent yet.

            However, the report confirms a familiar problem with regard to the outcome stage. While AAs are always present for interview, whether they stay through to decisions around charge and bail depends on delay length. Some AAs deliberately stay based on their judgment of what the individual child needs in terms of support at discharge. Lawyers often leave immediately after interview. This reinforces the AA role as not just an interview safeguard, but often the only independent person still actively supporting the child at the end of the custody process.

            National Standard 6.9 (Minimising detention)

            Indicator (g): "AAs seek to ensure children are never placed in cells with adults and are only placed in cells when no other secure accommodation is available in the station and it is not practicable to supervise them out of cell or a cell provides the most comfortable secure accommodation".

            National Standard 5.14 (Remote support)

            "Remote support is only ever used to enhance and not replace the physical presence of an AA and only where it is clearly in the best interests of a person who is in custody. (Indicators (a)-(g) are all highly relevant)"  

            National Standard 5.10 (Scope of support in custody)

            Indicator (i): "The scheme is structured and resourced appropriately to ensure that an AA is available in good time when required for the processes defined in the PACE Act and its Codes, including but not limited to: charging / disposals and related actions, including decisions about bail, local authority transfers and cautions or conditional cautions".

              7. Policing culture, detention and voluntary interviews

              Notably, where a child was brought in for a low-level arrest in the late evening, and it was not possible to progress the case immediately, custody officers described using ‘short bail’ in appropriate cases to avoid lengthy detention. Researchers felt this was preferable to ‘bedding down’ a child overnight, but raised the question about whether detention was necessary at all.

              Researchers found Surrey already made comparatively strong use of voluntary interviews (VI), yet the CHILD pilot did not lead to an increase. Officers described VI as more appropriate for children and often more productive, but frontline practice frequently defaulted to arrest because it was perceived as simpler, more familiar, or required to access certain investigative powers and safeguarding routes that are only triggered by detention. This tendency is reinforced when inexperienced officers lack confidence in managing complex situations without the structure of custody.

              The report highlights how policing culture shapes these decisions. Most officers embraced the child‑centred ethos of the pilot, but a minority expressed punitive attitudes, seeing custody as a deterrent and arguing against treating children differently from adults. Such views increase the likelihood that children will be brought into custody, particularly for low‑level matters.

              These cultural dynamics matter for AA schemes. When arrest is used by default, it is open to the AA to challenge unnecessary detention, ensuring alternatives are considered, and helping the child navigate an environment shaped as much by culture as by policy. AAs can support and encourage a diversion-focused culture, and is essential in challenging punitive instincts.

              National Standard 6.9 (Minimising detention)

              "A person who is detained is dealt with expeditiously with no unnecessary delays. They are released as soon as the need for detention no longer applies and, in the case of children (under 18) are transferred to alternative accommodation as required by law".

              8. Challenges for AAs

              The report also identifies familiar challenges for AA provision:

              • travel distances
              • capacity and resources to scale up when police activities drive up demand
              • some AAs preferring not to attend until interview
              • police custody perceptions that SAAVS is stretched
              • members of the custody team sometimes treating AAs “as if they work for us”
              National Standard 1.4 (Finance)

              "The scheme is appropriately resourced in order to operate sustainably and in adherence with all relevant legislation, codes and standards".

              National Standard 1.8 (Relationship with police)

              "The scheme has a positive working relationship with the police force based on mutual understanding and clear independence from one another".

              National Standard 3.5 (Need and purpose)

              "AAs understand the need for an AA, the overall purpose of the role, and the importance of actual and perceived independence from policing". 

              Want to know more...?

              Policy

              Vulnerability

              We're are not just working on identification. Did you know that while local authorities have a legal duty to provide an appropriate adult for children, there's no equivalent duty to provide one for vulnerable adults?

              Click below to find out more, and catch up on our latest activities, updates and media.

              Policy

              Our priorities

              We're working on a wide range of policy and practical issues, including:

              • Vulnerable adults
              • Children
              • Voluntary interviews
              • Strip and intimate searches
              • Remote legal advice
              • Accountability 

              Information

              About AAs

              The role of the appropriate adult is to safeguard the interests, rights, entitlements and welfare of children and vulnerable people who are suspected of a criminal offence, by ensuring that they are treated in a fair and just manner, and are able to participate effectively.