Local authority accommodation transfers
Police and local authorities share legal duties intended to ensure children don't stay in cells between being charged with an offence and appearing at court.
However, the legal framework is complicated and the system is under-resourced, resulting in systemic breaches of children's rights.
The problem
Legal duties to transfer children...
Once a child (under 18) is charged with an offence, the police must decide whether to release or detain them prior to their first appearance at court.
If they are detained they must usually be transferred to local authority accommodation.
Both the police and local authorities have legal duties regarding transfers.
...don't happen in practice.
The law recognises the psychological damage that detention can do to a child and is designed to ensure that children are detained for the minimum time necessary, as per the UK's obligations under the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (Article 37).
However, in large areas of England and Wales, these legal duties have been systematically ignored for many years.
Challenges
This is a long standing systemic issue, with many contributing factors.
Click on each part of the system below to find out more about the potential reasons for failure to transfer children from police cells to local authority accommodation.

- Sometimes ask for secure when it is not justified in the legislation. It can be culturally and psychologically challenging for a police officer to transfer a child to a non-secure environment after having refused bail.
- Sometimes interpret “impracticable” in the legislation as closer to "very difficult" than "impossible"
- Are expected to interpret unclear primary legislation (the ‘risk of serious harm to the public' is only defined in PACE 1984 in relation to certain violent and sexual offences, though they could argue the gravity of a different offence met this threshold)
- Believe it will take a long time or be impossible to arrange because they have lost faith in local authority provision (and therfore in effect the law itself)
- Think that the accommodation provided will be too far away and not allow a proper rest period and therefore not be in the child’s best interests
- Are sometime frustrated with the courts for not detaining peopel they arrest regularly
- Don’t approach other local authorities which may respond more positively
- Don't bill the home local authority when they don't provide accommodation
- Don’t always produce the required certificate to the court when a transfer is impracticable or secure accommodation is required but not available, so courts are not informed of individual of systemic failures
- Lack clarity and trust around who is responsible for the child arriving at court. The legislation, YJB, and College of Policing Approved Professional Practice say the responsibility for the child or young person passes from the police to the local authority. This transfer of responsibility includes transfer of the power to detain them and responsibility for ensuring that they appear at court. However, according to the IOPC, the police’s duty of care extends to the period after release from police custody and some local protocols say the child or young person remains technically in police custody and as such will not be allowed the leave the placement until their court appearance (except on health grounds)
- Interpret the legal exceptions to the transfer requirement (for example those arrested on a warrant) as suggesting that Parliament did not think police cells were that bad for a child
- Do not have satisfactory arrangements for monitoring/accountability.
- At the time PACE was developed and enacted had secure units, often attached to a non-secure children's home. Now there are only 15 secure children's homes for England and Wales, in which there are rarely more than two or three vacancies. Given referral/answer times of 2-3 hours and two-way travel time, this can make social workers judge that it is not in the best interests of a child to be transferred even where it is a legal requirement
- Don’t differentiate between refusal of bail and transfer (i.e. believe that if a child is refused bail they present a significant risk and must be kept locked up by police
- Faced with a request for a non-secure PACE bed undertake a risk assessment and conclude a secure bed is needed even when police don’t require it
- Feel unable to fund PACE accommodation constantly, just for occasional use
- May use secure if (a) likely to abscond or (b) likely to injure self or others in other accommodation (a double test beyond the police test to use secure if 12+ and risk to public of serious harm) but haven’t built enough secure accommodation (whether out of lack of consideration, choice having considered low demand and high cost, or pure financial limitations)
- Are not clear that they have a legal power to detain a child transferred under PACE
- Do not have satisfactory arrangements for monitoring/accountability.
- Should be involved from the start in identifying possible concerns about bail and liaising with police to offer bail information / support to avoid need for PACE transfer (according to YJB guidance). Where AAs are not YOT staff, there are not always effective, real-time lines of communication back to the YOT
- Should be involved / consulted when a PACE transfer is being enacted.

- Do not have sufficient awareness/understanding of children's right to a transfer
- May not be present or otherwise involved at the point in time in which decisions about bail, detention and transfers are made
- Do not have effective lines of communication back to the Youth Offending Team

- Do not often call police to account in relation to transfers under.38(6) and certificates under s.38(7) or call Directors of Social Services to account under s.21(2)(b) Childrens Act. Where either police or LA has failed, the lack of transfer is unlawful and open to compensation.
- Are not aware of the issue and do not have satisfactory arrangements for monitoring/accountability
- Amended the Children Act 1989, via the Secure Accommodation Regulations 1991, in a way which made it more likely that children will be sent to secure accommodation. In practice, as secure accommodation is less common and the local authority duty to provide accommodation is only absolute in relation to non-secure, this is likely to decrease the number transfers. The normal test for secure under Children Act 1989 s. 25 is "has a history of absconding AND if he does so he is likely to suffer significant harm; or is likely to injure self or others if in other accommodation". The 1991 regulations changed this when it is applied in the contect of s.38(6) to "likely to abscond from other accommodation; or likely to injure self or others if in other accommodation" - a much lower threshold.
- Cuts to local government funding have made it increasingly diffcult to ensure the provision of suitable accommodation for children
- Secure accommodation for children is effectively limited to Secure Children's Homes, of which there are only a small number.
Our solutions
1. Policy
In 2014, NAAN highlighted the issue of local authority accommodation transfers with its first flowchart guidance (see below).
In 2016, the Welsh Government embedded the NAAN flowchart into its first All-Wales guidance for the appropriate management and transfer of children and young people by the Police and Local Authorities.
NAAN was also a key contributor as a member of the Home Office working group on local authority transfers, which developed the national Concordat on Children in Custody published in 2017.
Inspired by the national concordat, this led the London Safeguarding Children Board to develop the London Protocol for the provision of local authority accommodation for children held in police custody in 2019.
Today, NAAN continues to encourage the Home Office and Ministry of Justice to develop a system of recording and reporting failure to transfer children, based on the certificates that police are legally required to present to courts.
2. Legal
NAAN supported the Just for Kids Law No child in cells campaign, which from 2016 brought a series of legal challenges against police forces and local authorities concerning the unlawful detention of children in police cells overnight, and in 2022 published research and recommendations for ending the overnight detention of children in police custody.
NAAN provided expert witness testimony for the judicial review of non-compliance with the legal requirements, driven by Just for Kids Law.
3. Practice
NAAN developed a detailed flow-chart to help everyone navigate the complex legal framework ensure children’s rights are met. First published in 2014, we updated it 2018 and again in 2026 to reflect the changing case law.
Here's a preview of "Post-charge detention of children: A guide to transferring children refused police bail to local authority accommodation".
Click the button to download a PDF version with live links to all the relevant legal references.
Want to know more...?
Strip searches
Whether it is strip searches or intimate searches of children, in police custody or under stop and search, the system of police powers is complex. And the safeguards are more limited than most people realise.
Click below to find out more, and catch up on our latest activities, updates and media.
Join us
NAAN is a charity and membership organisation, working to create a fairer justice system for children and vulnerable adults by maximising the effectiveness of the appropriate adult safeguard.
We provide a centre of expertise and a community for anyone interested in the appropriate adult role.
About AAs
Aappropriate adults safeguard the interests, rights, entitlements and welfare of children and vulnerable people suspected of a criminal offence, by ensuring that they are treated in a fair and just manner, and can participate effectively.
AA schemes for children are a statutory youth justice service, whether delivered by a YJS or provider.
