Skip to main content

Public articles

What is an appropriate adult?

How is child defined?

Police custody

Voluntary interviews

Stop and search

Want to stay informed?


What is an appropriate adult?

The term appropriate adult is now used in several different contexts, including:

  • Police custody: When a child or vulnerable person is detained in police custody, or agrees to a voluntary interview under caution (as required by the Police and Criminal Evidence Act, Code C)
  • Voluntary interviews: When a child or vulnerable person is interviewed (questioned) voluntarily under caution (as required by the Police and Criminal Evidence Act, Code C)
  • Stop and search: When a child or vulnerable person is subjected to a more thorough search that exposes intimate parts of their body (as required by the Police and Criminal Evidence Act, Code A)
  • Scotland: While the above applies to England and Wales (and in a slightly modified way in Northern Ireland), Scotland is a separate and distinct jurisdiction where the role of the appropriate adult is significantly different (focusing entirely on communication)
  • Age-assessment: When an unaccompanied asylum-seeking child is subjected to an age-assessment interview be a local authority (as required by various case law).

Distinct from these legally-defined uses of the term, “appropriate adult” is also frequently used in a more informal manner, to simply refer to the need for an adult to be present, and for that adult not to be inappropriate.

Therefore, whenever the term is used, it is important to be clear about exactly what is meant.

The National Appropriate Adult Network (NAAN) provides information and support solely on the role of the appropriate adult as defined by the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984.

We are unable to provide guidance on:

  • other roles which have been given the same title
  • the wider safeguarding responsibilities of schools and other educational establishments
  • the role of the appropriate adult with suspects in Scotland.

How is child defined?

The Police and Criminal Evidence Act (PACE) uses the term ‘juvenile’ rather than ‘child’ or ‘young person’. Under PACE, a juvenile is anyone up to and including 17 years of age.

NAAN refers to anyone up to and including 17 years of age, as per the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child.

The minimum age of criminal responsibility in England and Wales is 10 years old – so this is relevant to primary school children.


Police custody

The police are required to contact an appropriate adult whenever they detain a child in custody, as a suspect, as part of a criminal or terrorism investigation.

If you are seeking information about the role of an appropriate adult in police custody, we can provide support in a number of ways:


Voluntary interviews

There are specific legal thresholds that must be met for a child to be arrested and detained in police custody.

Where these are not met, the police can still ask to interview someone as a suspect ‘under caution’.

This is variously referred to as a:

  • voluntary interview
  • voluntary attendance
  • caution plus 3

They may take place at a police station or other setting.

An appropriate adult must be present whenever a child or vulnerable person is interviewed (questioned) as a suspect in a criminal or terrorism investigation. This includes when that person has not been arrested but has agreed voluntarily to be interviewed under caution. This is not a matter of choice for the child or vulnerable person. It is a requirement on police. This applies even if they choose not to answer any of the questions.

Questioning in educational establishments

Under the Police and Criminal Evidence Act Code C:

  • As soon as the police have grounds to suspect that a person has committed an offence, they must read the ‘caution’ and ensure the person understands it, before any questions are put to them.
  • The caution is not necessary when police ask questions for other purposes (for example, solely to establish someone's identity or their ownership of a certain vehicle, or in in the proper and effective conduct of a search, e.g. to determine the need to search in the exercise of powers of stop and search or to seek co-operation while carrying out a search).
  • But if initial questions, become questioning about a person's involvement or suspected involvement in a criminal offence, the caution (in the presence of an AA) is required.
  • Under 18’s should only be interviewed in their place of education in exceptional circumstances (11.16)
  • The principal, or their nominee, must agree to the interview (11.16)
  • Every effort should be made to notify the child’s parent, or person responsible for their welfare, of the police’s intention to interview (11.16)
  • Reasonable time should be provided to enable the appropriate adult to be present (11.16)
  • In determining who the appropriate adult will be, priority must be given to the parent, guardian or, if the juvenile is in the care of a local authority or voluntary organisation, a person representing that authority or organisation (1.7)
  • The principal of the school, or their nominee, can only act in the role if waiting for the appropriate adult would cause unreasonable delay. The allegation must also not be an offence against the school (11.16)

For further information about the AA role in voluntary interviews:


Stop and search

There are three different levels of search, involving:

  • Removal of jackets, outer garments and gloves (JOG) – similar to the powers of schools
  • A more thorough search (MTS) – can be done out of public view, in a police vehicle, or in a police station
  • Exposure of intimate parts of the body (EIP) – can only be done out of public view or in a police station

Exposure of intimate parts of the body

An appropriate adult is only required for a search that exposes intimate parts of the body (EIP search).

The role of an appropriate adult is the same as it is when a child or vulnerable person is detained in police custody and subjected to a strip search.

Police are expected to consult a supervisor prior to carrying out an EIP, to explore the reasons why it is necessary and proportionate in the circumstances. The supervisor’s role in this context is to support and encourage good decision making by providing suitable challenge.

For more information about searches that expose intimate parts of the body, and the related role of an appropriate adult, we recommend the following resources:

Child Q

In March 2022, there was intense media interest in the case of Child Q. Child Q was subjected by police to a search which exposed intimate parts of her body. The search occured on school premises, after teachers had called the police because they believed Child Q smelled of cannabis.

In light of this particularly disturbing case, we recommend the following additional resources:

The IOPC has recommended that the smell of cannabis alone should not be considered reasonable grounds for a search:

Please note that NAAN cannot provide guidance on the overall safeguarding responsibilities of educational establishments.


Staying Informed

We are currently discussing how we can act further in this area, through policy work and/or practical support. If you would like to be informed of any developments, please register your interest.

Register your interest

Being an appropriate adult: implementation

Thank you for your interest in our Being an appropriate adult video.

The information on this page is intended to help your organisation make the best use of this resource. It is focused on police forces which are interested in adopting the video as part of their processes. However, we hope it will also be of use to others, including lawyers and community organisations.

“Guidance for non-specialist AAs, recently produced by the National Appropriate Adult Network, is available in video format accessed online via a QR code on prominently displayed posters in all custody suite booking in areas. Written guidance is also available for custody officers to print and provide to AAs”.

Report on an inspection visit to police custody suites in Lincolnshire (August 2022)

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Who is the target audience for the video?

    The video is designed for people who have been, or may be asked, asked by police to be an appropriate adult. It is aimed at:

    • family members
    • friends
    • and others who are being asked to be the appropriate adult because they are known to the person for whom an AA is required.  

    It is designed to be applicable whether the person they are supporting is:

    • a child under 18, or
    • a vulnerable person as defined by PACE Code C.

    It is also designed to be relevant whether the person is:

    • detained in police custody
    • attending a voluntary interview under caution. 

    The video does not replace:

  • How can people watch the video?

    Viewing via an internet browser

    The video is available at www.vimeo.com/appropriateadult/video. 

    You can also see it here on our website, along with our written guides for AAs. We recommend that you use the Vimeo link when sharing with appropriate adults, as this will not change wiht any changes to our website.

    The video can be viewed via any normal internet browser, whether on:

    • a computer (desktop or laptop) or
    • mobile device (smartphone or tablet).
    Viewing offline in the Vimeo app

    An alternative to viewing via a browser is viewing in the Vimeo app. 

    Using the app, people attending as appropriate adults can make the video ‘available offline’ before they enter custody. However, please note the following:

    • Chapters (shortcuts to key sections) are not available
    • Closed captions and subtitles are not available
    • Analytics do not function (views will not be counted in our data)
    • It will only be viewable in that Vimeo app (you can’t save the file on another device).

    The instructions for making the video available offline are:

    1. Using Wi-Fi or phone data download the Vimeo app to an Android or iOs mobile device (there is no requirement to register a Vimeo account but this is free if desired).
    2. Search for “Being an appropriate adult” from NAAN and tap on the video
    3. Pause the video and tap on the three dots to the right of the video title
    4. Tap “Make available offline”
    5. Wait until the video downloads (the bar below the video fills up blue and you should get a notification to say the download is complete).

    To check the video is available offline and access it later:

    1. In the Vimeo app, click on the ‘Home’ tab (not the Videos or Watch tabs)
    2. Tap on the account icon in the top right corner (a blue smiley face unless changed by user)
    3. Under ‘Library’, tap ‘Offline’
    4. Tap to watch the video.
  • Is there any cost for using the video?

    No. The video is public access and can be used in custody completely free. We have also provided free poster designs that you can print locally.

  • What resources are available to promote the video?

    We've created a poster to help spread awareness of the video, and provide access to it. 

    The poster has an embedded QR code. Pointing a smartphone camera at this QR code provides a direct link to the video. Alternatively, the web address can be typed into a browser manually.

    You can print the poster at whatever size you wish, but we recommend A3 or larger.

    You can download the poster with crop marks or without crop marks. 

    It is also available in Welsh and Welsh and English.

    2022 being AA poster

  • Who produced the video?

    The project was a partnership between Dr Miranda Bevan and the National Appropriate Adult Network (NAAN).

    Dr Bevan’s research focuses on vulnerable suspects and defendants, police custody, effective participation and unfitness to plead. Her leadership of this project was funded by the London School of Economics and the Economic and Social Research Council (part of UK Research and Innovation)

    NAAN is a charity and membership organisation, and the national centre of expertise on the appropriate adult role. It is funded by the Home Office, charitable funders and its own income from membership, training and events. NAAN’s contribution to the project was led by Chief Executive Chris Bath, a member of the Home Office PACE Strategy Board.

  • Who is supporting the video and its national roll out?

    The video has a wide range of support including:

    • Home Office 
    • National Police Chiefs’ Council (via ACC Nev Kemp, custody lead)

    The video has even won support in the UK Parliament from both Government and Opposition. 

  • Which police forces are using the video?

    The video was piloted in custody by Northamptonshire Police. 

    It is now available for all forces.

    We are aware that the video is being used in the following forces:

    • Durham 
    • Essex
    • Kent
    • Northamptonshire
    • South Yorkshire
    • Merseyside
    • Metropolitan Police Service
    • Greater Manchester

    If you let us know of any other forces using the video, we’ll add the force name here.

  • What are the benefits to police forces of using the video?

    Meeting PACE requirements

    PACE Code C 3.17A requires that “The custody officer must ensure that at the time the copy of the notice [of rights and entitlements] is given to the appropriate adult, or as soon as practicable thereafter, the appropriate adult is advised of the duties of the appropriate adult as described in paragraph 1.7A”.

    Meeting inspection expectations

    HMICFRS/HMIP custody inspections repeatedly identify issues regarding the police's communication with parents in the role of appropriate adult. 

    Expectation 4.5 addresses appropriate adults. It requires that, “The parents or guardians of those under 18 are used whenever they are willing, able and suitable for the role of appropriate adult. They are given written guidance on the role and are encouraged to actively protect the child’s rights”.

    Providing access to the video will indicate a commitment to encouraging active protection of rights.

    The Expectations are about to be revised and HMICFRS have indicated that the new version will include:

    • The use of other media in addition to written guidance (e.g. video)
    • Reference to both children and vulnerable adults (in line with PACE Code C).

    NAAN also provides free written guidance which police forces can provide to appropriate adults, either by printing or sending web links.   

    Delivering the NPCC Custody Strategy

    The video can help forces to deliver on a number of elements in the forthcoming (April 2022) NPCC custody strategy.  For example, it will help forces to demonstrate how they are: 

    • Considering the welfare and dignity of all detainees at all times. 
    • Treat all detainees with respect, proactively protecting their rights.
    • Working effectively and respectfully with all those who visit police custody
    • Accountable for their actions, encouraging independent scrutiny
    • Working in partnership to ensure that custody is safe and efficient
    • Investing in new technology and solutions that support safety, welfare, rights, dignity and efficiency
    • Innovating and seeking new and improved ways to provide excellent service
    • Invest in the custody estate to ensure a safe and welcoming environment.
    Preventing deaths in and after custody

    The Report of the Independent Review of Deaths and Serious Incidents in Police Custody highlighted the importance of the appropriate adult role. Dame Angiolini wrote: 

    ""However, custody can have a traumatising effect on children (as indeed it can with adults) and the risks of self inflicted death following release should not be downplayed".

    The video provides an opportunity for engagement with parents - one which builds their capacity to play a positive role in the process. Early and effective AA support will reduce the trauma of custody, and this requires a well-informed parent. 

    Reducing complaints

    Ensuring that appropriate adults are well informed about their role, and the rights of a child or vulnerable person, encourages the early solution of issues that would otherwise escalate into complaints. This is both more effective for the investigation, and more effective than dealing with complaints after the fact, once people have learned more about the role and rights. 

    Improving efficiency, effectiveness and legitimacy

    Research evidence clearly indicates that family member, and other untrained appropriate adults, are often poorly informed about the AA role.

    Direct police explanations of the role have several limitations:

    • It takes a lot of officer time to do properly
    • Officers are often not trained on the role of the appropriate adult themselves
    • The role may be explained differently by each officer
    • The explanation of the role can emphasise elements that are most important from a police perspective, such as facilitation of communication in interview
    • The independence of the role may not be as clear when explained by police
    • The emotion of the situation can present additional challenges.

    In contrast, ensuring that people have access to, and have viewed, independent information:

    • Reduces time and cognitive burdens on busy officers
    • Increases consistency of the information provided
    • Guarantees that information is accurate
    • Demonstrates that police are willing to provide independent information about the rights of the suspect and appropriate adult, and to respect those rights
    • Encourages a relationship of trust, support and collaboration between the appropriate adult and custody staff, in protecting the rights, welfare and participation of the person
    • Has been shown to calm and focus people on their role as appropriate adult
  • How detailed is the video?

    The appropriate adult role is hugely complex, with the national standards requiring around 20 hours of training for AAs from organised schemes. At the same time, it is an emotional situation for parents, and too much information is not necessarily helpful or digestible.

    The video was designed to balance comprehensiveness with accessibility. At 9 minutes long, it provides a ‘comprehensive summary’.

    NAAN also provides written guidance which can also be provided to appropriate adults.

  • How can police forces best use the video?

    We’ve piloted the video in custody with Northamptonshire Police.

    When we envisaged this project, our focus was on the independence of this information from police. We felt this was an important way to mirror the independence of the AA role, and also overcome any trust issues that may exist between individuals and the police.  

    However, Northamptonshire saw it a bit differently! They were keen to embed the video in their own processes, to support them to meet their responsibilities under PACE to inform AAs of their role. . While this was different to our original vision, we could not ignore the benefits.

    The pilot identified a number of benefits but it also identified some challenges, including:

    • a lack of WiFi in custody
    • old technology preventing some custody staff from accessing online links
    • the comprehensiveness of the video slowing down processes if shown at the custody desk
    • people being in a distressed state when then attend as appropriate adult
    • police wanting to be assured that the video had been viewed.

    Here’s a summary of the ways that Northamptonshire overcame these challenges.

    Before AA arrival
    • When requesting that the person attends as AA, custody staff sent them the web link (by email or text) so they can watch before arrival.
    • This could include instructions for making the video available offline on their device.

    Police station

    • Posters with QR codes were downloaded, printed at A3, laminated and put up in both in the waiting area and custody
    Custody process
    • Initially, detention officers took people outside to view the video (while this time consuming, it was noted that it delivered benefits in terms of relationships)
    • Later, a laptop with limited web access (via wired connection rather than Wi-Fi) was set up in a consultation room, and detention officers took people into the consultation room to view the video.
  • Is the video available in other languages?

    The project did not include funding for alternative languages. 

    However, thanks to the generous support of www.thebigword.com we have been able to provide subtitles in the following lanugages:

    • Albanian (coming soon)
    • Bulgarian (coming soon)
    • Lithuanian (live)
    • Romanian (live)
    • Urdu (live)

    We would warmly welcome offers to provide professional grade translations of our caption/subtitles files. Please email This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. 

  • Can we have a download of the video?

    Downloads of the video are not currently available. The video must be accessed online. 

    We appreciate that there are difficulties with access to the internet in some custody facilities. We want as many people to see this as possible. And we want to make it as easy as possible for forces to support us in doing that. The ability to download the video onto a local system is an obvious solution. We know that several forces are interested in using rugged tablets or video books for share information with people detained in custody.  

    However, there are a number of issues with using that approach for this video, which we set out below. That said, if you are keen to use the video, we're keen to hear from you. We're very happy to work together to try to find a way forward. 

    1. Version control

    Holding the video centrally and online means that updates to the video are live instantly, everywhere. There is no need for police forces to keep checking whether their version is out of date. If we allowed downloads, we’d end up with different versions all over the country.

    2. Subtitles and captions

    The online platform (Vimeo) allows us to add captions and/or subtitles. We’re hoping to create subtitles for many other languages. With online hosting, these will be available everywhere as soon as we upload them, as will any changes we need to make. As the subtitles are part of the platform, rather than the video, no subtitles would be included in a download.

    3. Navigation

    Vimeo also allows us to add ‘chapters’ to the video. At 9 minutes, the video is fairly long. Chapters allow us to break down the video into its natural sections. This means viewers can easily refer back to sections of interest, rather than simply watching the video once. As the chapters are part of the platform, rather than the video, they would not be included in a download.

    4. Analytics

    Holding the video online means that we can get data about how its being used. This includes where in the country it is being viewed, how many people are seeing it, and at what point they stop watching it. The video is provided for free, and the project funding is complete. In order to maintain our support for the video, we’ll need to be able to demonstrate this kind of impact data to future funders of the charity. These analytics are not available when a downloaded video is played. Instead, we’d have to find a way for each force to manually provide that data. Even if we could find a way, it would mean taking back the time and effort we were hoping to save police officers!

  • How can we support access to the video in custody?

    There are number of options and forces can select from as many as they are able to do:

    • Providing appropriate adults with a link to the video (by email and/or text) when requesting their attendance (we strongly encourage this in all implementations)
    • Allowing apporpriate adults to bring their mobile device into custody unless there are specific known reasons why this is not possible
    • Requesting that the relevant webpages are 'whitelisted' by your information department
    • If adding to the whitelist is not permitted, but the force's own website is already whitelisted, we would be happy to discuss This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..
    • Providing the AA with a mobile device with access to the relevant web pages 
    • If there is no Wi-Fi, setting up a laptop in a consultation room with a wired (ethernet) connection to the internet, with support from custody staff to view.

    Also see:

    • How can police forces best use the video?
    • How can people watch the video? 

Continue reading

The PACE Act 1984 instructs police to first seek a parent to perform the AA role. If neither a parent or social worker is available, they can ask anyone else who is over 18. The Crime and Disorder Act 1998 makes it a statutory duty for Youth Offending Teams to ‘ensure the provision’ of AAs for children.

The result is that organised appropriate adult schemes only support around one third of arrested children. But who is best placed to fulfil the appropriate adult role?

Some argue that an unreasonable expectation is being placed on parents. How can they be expected to safeguard a child effectively against breaches of the immense PACE Act and complex Codes of Practice? This is even more challenging given the fact that it’s an emotional experience when your child is arrested – perhaps especially if it is the first time or a serious allegation.

In contrast, under the NAAN national standards new appropriate adults should be given 20 hours of training and two shadowing visits to police custody. Whether they are paid or a volunteer, they have a professional relationship with the child rather than an emotional one. Over time, they have opportunity to develop a deep understanding of the PACE Codes and the confidence to challenge police practice.

However, others argue that parental responsibility is a decisive factor. Furthermore, no matter how well a professional AA) is trained, it is unlikely that they will know the child and their individual needs. And of course, there is the argument that the taxpayer does not have to pay for parents.

When considered objectively, academic evidence certainly suggests that parents are not effective appropriate adults. As we highlighted in a recent literature review, the use of family members as AAs for children is fraught with difficulty. Problems with the use of parents as AAs for children include; a misunderstanding of the AA role, the threat of physical violence towards their child, pressure on their child to confess, aggression towards police and their involvement in ongoing family conflicts. Even the best intentioned, most educated and assertive are challenged by a lack of knowledge and their emotional state. Some parents will be naturally compliant or hostile towards the police – neither of which is likely to deliver the best outcomes for a child.

NAAN’s view is that, while parents cannot be expected to understand PACE, they should not be excluded from the process (unless they are genuinely inappropriate).

Parents hold knowledge about an individual child that may be critical to ensuring they can participate effectively in the process. Professional appropriate adults have an understanding of custody procedures, rights and entitlements that is critical to providing an effective safeguard.

Rather than making an either/or decision, NAAN would like to see policy and practice develop to support a collaborative model. Such a model would be dynamic, allowing information and responsibilities to be shared across parents and providers. This might involve parents sharing information with a professional before they attend, or even AA services coaching a parent as they take on the role.

The lack of availability of appropriate adults 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, has been cited by campaigners as contributing to the overnight detention of children. Police have also been critical of the lack of AA services out of hours.

The majority of AAs for children are parents. For some, attending outside office hours will be easier, while others it may be more difficult – for example due to child care commitments. So what expectations should be placed on organised AA schemes?

From a legal perspective, PACE does not specify times during which police cannot conduct interviews or other investigatory procedures. The statutory duty on Youth Offending Teams to ensure provision of an AA does not specify operational hours or any other limit on the duty. Therefore, it is clear that AA schemes for children should have the ability to respond whenever they are needed.

HM Inspectoprate of Contabulary's expectations for police custody require that, "Independent appropriate adult schemes for children and vulnerable adults are in place, operate to relevant national standards and are used". One of the indicators for this is that AAs are available 24 hours a day.

However, this does not mean that schemes are bound to always provide an AA when the police request one in order to carry out an interview or other procedure.

PACE Code C states that, “in any period of 24 hours a detainee must be allowed a continuous period of at least 8 hours for rest, free from questioning, travel or any interruption in connection with the investigation concerned. This period should normally be at night or other appropriate time which takes account of when the detainee last slept or rested.”

The AA scheme has a duty to ensure this right is met. In so doing, they may reasonably refuse to enable police procedures where they conflict with the right. Police should not be enabled to interview when a child is not alert. However, this is not justification for a fixed policy of not attending after a certain time. The decision must be made on the basis of the individual child’s best interest, after consideration of their particular sleep/wake cycle and level of alertness.

The YOT’s statutory duty is to ensure the provision of AAs to safeguard the interests of children and young persons, not the convenience of police officers. The police are under obligation to minimise the time children spend in detention. The ability of schemes to provide or withhold an AA can be a powerful tool in ensuring children’s cases are expedited.

Current Youth Justice Board guidance captures the nuance effectively, stating, “This duty applies at any time of day or night. You should consider requests for attendance out-of-hours in line with the best interests of the individual child.”

It must also be recognised that, while a small number of AA schemes have informed NAAN that they are operating 24/7 services, many do not currently have the resources to provide such a service. In order to meet the increasing expectations and current legal duties, it is likely that resources will need to be increased above current levels.

For youth justice professionals

Appropriate adults for children are a statutory youth justice service.

Youth justice staff may be asked to act as appropriate adults, or work in partnership with them to support children in police custody and interviews.

  • National standards

    The NAAN National Standards are approved by the Youth Justice Board. Under the standards for children in the youth justice system (2019), set by the Secretary of State for Justice on the advice of the Youth Justice Board (YJB), the provision of appropriate adults must be in line with the NAAN National Standards.

    Read: NAAN National Standards

  • Bail and remand

    Appropriate adult provision is part of a youth justice services's bail and remand strategy. 

    The Youth Justice Board includes guidance on appropriate adults within its case management guidance on how to manage bail and remands.

     

  • Local authority accommodation

    When a child under 18 is refused police bail, with few exceptions they must be transferred to local authority accommodation pending the first available court appearance. 

    This is an important part of minimising detention times for children, which is a requirement under the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child. 

    Find out more about the challenges and download our flowchart "Post-charge detention of children: A guide to transferring children refused police bail to local authority accommodation"

    Local authority transfers flowchart

Continue reading

The following information is provided for nurses and other healthcare professionals.

Local authority accommodation transfers

Police and local authorities share legal duties intended to ensure children don't stay in cells between being charged with an offence and appearing at court.

However, the legal framework is complicated and the system is under-resourced, resulting in systemic breaches of children's rights.

Download the flowchart (PDF)

The problem

Legal duties to transfer children...

Once a child (under 18) is charged with an offence, the police must decide whether to release or detain them prior to their first appearance at court.

If they are detained they must usually be transferred to local authority accommodation. 

Both the police and local authorities have legal duties regarding transfers.

...don't happen in practice.

The law recognises the psychological damage that detention can do to a child and is designed to ensure that children are detained for the minimum time necessary, as per the UK's obligations under the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (Article 37).

However, in large areas of England and Wales, these legal duties have been systematically ignored for many years. 

Challenges

This is a long standing systemic issue, with many contributing factors. 

Click on each part of the system below to find out more about the potential reasons for failure to transfer children from police cells to local authority accommodation.

  • Police

    • Sometimes ask for secure when it is not justified in the legislation. It can be culturally and psychologically challenging for a police officer to transfer a child to a non-secure environment after having refused bail. 
    • Sometimes interpret “impracticable” in the legislation as closer to "very difficult" than "impossible"
    • Are expected to interpret unclear primary legislation (the ‘risk of serious harm to the public' is only defined in PACE 1984 in relation to certain violent and sexual offences, though they could argue the gravity of a different offence met this threshold)
    • Believe it will take a long time or be impossible to arrange because they have lost faith in local authority provision (and therfore in effect the law itself)
    • Think that the accommodation provided will be too far away and not allow a proper rest period and therefore not be in the child’s best interests
    • Are sometime frustrated with the courts for not detaining peopel they arrest regularly 
    • Don’t approach other local authorities which may respond more positively
    • Don't bill the home local authority when they don't provide accommodation
    • Don’t always produce the required certificate to the court when a transfer is impracticable or secure accommodation is required but not available, so courts are not informed of individual of systemic failures
    • Lack clarity and trust around who is responsible for the child arriving at court. The legislation, YJB, and College of Policing Approved Professional Practice say the responsibility for the child or young person passes from the police to the local authority. This transfer of responsibility includes transfer of the power to detain them and responsibility for ensuring that they appear at court. However, according to the IOPC, the police’s duty of care extends to the period after release from police custody and some local protocols say the child or young person remains technically in police custody and as such will not be allowed the leave the placement until their court appearance (except on health grounds)
    • Interpret the legal exceptions to the transfer requirement (for example those arrested on a warrant) as suggesting that Parliament did not think police cells were that bad for a child
    • Do not have satisfactory arrangements for monitoring/accountability.
  • Local authorities

    • At the time PACE was developed and enacted had secure units, often attached to a non-secure children's home. Now there are only 15 secure children's homes for England and Wales, in which there are rarely more than two or three vacancies. Given referral/answer times of 2-3 hours and two-way travel time, this can make social workers judge that it is not in the best interests of a child to be transferred even where it is a legal requirement
    • Don’t differentiate between refusal of bail and transfer (i.e. believe that if a child is refused bail they present a significant risk and must be kept locked up by police
    • Faced with a request for a non-secure PACE bed undertake a risk assessment and conclude a secure bed is needed even when police don’t require it
    • Feel unable to fund PACE accommodation constantly, just for occasional use
    • May use secure if (a) likely to abscond or (b) likely to injure self or others in other accommodation (a double test beyond the police test to use secure if 12+ and risk to public of serious harm) but haven’t built enough secure accommodation (whether out of lack of consideration,  choice having considered low demand and high cost, or pure financial limitations)
    • Are not clear that they have a legal power to detain a child transferred under PACE
    • Do not have satisfactory arrangements for monitoring/accountability.
  • Youth Justice Services

    • Should be involved from the start in identifying possible concerns about bail and liaising with police to offer bail information / support to avoid need for PACE transfer (according to YJB guidance). Where AAs are not YOT staff, there are not always effective, real-time lines of communication back to the YOT
    • Should be involved / consulted when a PACE transfer is being enacted.
  • Appropriate adults

    • Do not have sufficient awareness/understanding of children's right to a transfer
    • May not be present or otherwise involved at the point in time in which decisions about bail, detention and transfers are made
    • Do not have effective lines of communication back to the Youth Offending Team
  • Courts

    • Do not often call police to account in relation to transfers under.38(6) and certificates under s.38(7) or call Directors of Social Services to account under s.21(2)(b) Childrens Act. Where either police or LA has failed, the lack of transfer is unlawful and open to compensation. 
  • Local Safeguarding Children’s Boards

    • Are not aware of the issue and do not have satisfactory arrangements for monitoring/accountability
  • Government

    • Amended the Children Act 1989, via the Secure Accommodation Regulations 1991, in a way which made it more likely that children will be sent to secure accommodation. In practice, as secure accommodation is less common and the local authority duty to provide accommodation is only absolute in relation to non-secure, this is likely to decrease the number  transfers. The normal test for secure under Children Act 1989 s. 25 is "has a history of absconding AND if he does so he is likely to suffer significant harm; or is likely to injure self or others if in other accommodation". The 1991 regulations changed this when it is applied in the contect of s.38(6) to "likely to abscond from other accommodation; or likely to injure self or others if in other accommodation" - a much lower threshold.
    • Cuts to local government funding have made it increasingly diffcult to ensure the provision of suitable accommodation for children
    • Secure accommodation for children is effectively limited to Secure Children's Homes, of which there are only a small number. 

Our solutions

  • 1. Policy

    In 2014, NAAN highlighted the issue of local authority accommodation transfers with its first flowchart guidance (see below). 

    In 2016, the Welsh Government embedded the NAAN flowchart into its first All-Wales guidance for the appropriate management and transfer of children and young people by the Police and Local Authorities. 

    NAAN was also a key contributor as a member of the Home Office working group on local authority transfers, which developed the national Concordat on Children in Custody published in 2017.

    Inspired by the national concordat, this led the London Safeguarding Children Board to develop the London Protocol for the provision of local authority accommodation for children held in police custody in 2019.

    Today, NAAN continues to encourage the Home Office and Ministry of Justice to develop a system of recording and reporting failure to transfer children, based on the certificates that police are legally required to present to courts.

  • 2. Legal

    NAAN supported the Just for Kids Law No child in cells campaign, which from 2016 brought a series of legal challenges against police forces and local authorities concerning the unlawful detention of children in police cells overnight, and in 2022 published research and recommendations for ending the overnight detention of children in police custody. 

    NAAN provided expert witness testimony for the  judicial review of non-compliance with the legal requirements, driven by Just for Kids Law.

  • 3. Practice

    NAAN developed a detailed flow-chart to help everyone navigate the complex legal framework ensure children’s rights are met. First published in 2014, we updated it 2018 and again in 2026 to reflect the changing case law.

    Here's a preview of "Post-charge detention of children: A guide to transferring children refused police bail to local authority accommodation".

    Click the button to download a PDF version with live links to all the relevant legal references.

  • Download the flowchart (PDF)

Want to know more...?

Strip searches

Policy

Whether it is strip searches or intimate searches of children, in police custody or under stop and search, the system of police powers is complex. And the safeguards are more limited than most people realise. 

Click below to find out more, and catch up on our latest activities, updates and media.

Read more

Join us

Membership

NAAN is a charity and membership organisation, working to create a fairer justice system for children and vulnerable adults by maximising the effectiveness of the appropriate adult safeguard.

We provide a centre of expertise and a community for anyone interested in the appropriate adult role.

Explore membership benefits

About AAs

Information

Aappropriate adults safeguard the interests, rights, entitlements and welfare of children and vulnerable people suspected of a criminal offence, by ensuring that they are treated in a fair and just manner, and can participate effectively.

AA schemes for children are a statutory youth justice service, whether delivered by a YJS or provider.

Read more

Continue reading

Our members

Organisations are eligible for full membership if they are in England and Wales and providing appropriate adult services.

Organisations and individuals are eligible for associate membership if they are connected with appropriate adult services and have a specific interest in promoting good practice in the role of the appropriate adult. Or if they provide appropriate adults in an area outside of England and Wales.

Full members

Full members can stand for election to the Board and vote at the AGM. They must be: 

  • an appropriate adult provider organisation; and
  • in England or Wales.

Associate members

Associate members are members who are:

  • not appropriate adult provider organisations; or
  • based outside of England and Wales.

[Last updated: 16/11/2026]

Continue reading

PACE requirements to secure an AA

AA provision by organised schemes

Joint Interim Interview Protocol (JIIP)


PACE requirements to secure an AA

PACE and its Codes of Practice have not been amended during the Covid-19 pandemic. Police officers are required to secure the involvement of an AA for the same processes and procedures as prior to the pandemic. This includes the need to secure the attendance of an AA (as opposed to a remote / live link) for several procedures, including interviews.

AA provision by organised schemes

AA schemes have continued to attend police custody throughout Covid-19 pandemic. This is in line with NAAN guidance, which states that AAs should continue to attend custody, subject to:

  1. The detention being necessary
  2. Suitable PPE being available in line with the NPCC PPE guidance
  3. The custody suite is being run in line with national health and safety / PPE guidance.

Joint Interim Interview Protocol (JIIP)

The JIIP was originally agreed in March 2020 between the Crown Prosecution Service, National Police Chiefs' Council, The Law Society, Criminal Law Solicitors’ Association and London Criminal Courts Solicitors’ Association. It was intended as short-term emergency guidance to assist investigators and prosecutors in deciding whether suspects should be interviewed as part of a police investigation during the coronavirus pandemic. It also encourages the use of remote advice for suspects - a practice that is not covered by the PACE Act or Codes of Practice.

On the publication of the JIIP, NAAN encouraged the signatories to consider the lack of safeguards for children and vulnerable adult suspects. Version 2 of the JIIP introduced safeguards, including the need for police to carry out individual assessments of suitability and to secure the consent of the AA. However, these safeguards were not sufficiently effective in preventing disadvantage to suspects (and thereby risks to the reliability of evidence). The signatories agreed and, from 17 May 2021, JIIP version 3 excluded all children and vulnerable people from remote legal representation. This simplified the process for AAs, suspects and police.

JIIP version 4 (October 2021) introduced a presumption of in-person legal advice for all suspects, with four exceptions for when remote representation could be used. However, it also applied these exceptions to children and vulnerable adults. This conflicts with NAAN's understanding of the appropriate adult's duties and the suspect's rights in law.

After careful consideration, NAAN had concluded that we are uanble to advise AAs to agree to take part in interviews in which legal representation is to be provided remotely. However, AAs should continue to attend police custody in all cases. For further guidance, rationale and resources, please see the links below.

Position statement: remote legal representation

Update

January 2023

The signatories have published JIIP version 5. The revised version excludes the use of any remote legal advice and representation for any children and vulnerable adults in any circumstances, including the exceptions. With Covid restrictions now years in the past, and PACE continuing to require in-person legal advice, there remains no justification for remote legal advice.

Read JIIP v5

Executive Summary

This page provides information about NAAN's position with regard to the use of remote legal representation with children and vulnerable adults.

What is the Joint Interim Interview Protocol?

The Joint Interim Interview Protocol (JIIP) was originally agreed in March 2020 between the Crown Prosecution Service, National Police Chiefs' Council, The Law Society, Criminal Law Solicitors’ Association and London Criminal Courts Solicitors’ Association. It was intended as short-term emergency guidance to assist investigators and prosecutors in deciding whether suspects should be interviewed as part of a police investigation during the coronavirus pandemic. It also encourages the use of remote advice for suspects - a practice that is not covered by the PACE Act or Codes of Practice. 

On the publication of the JIIP (early April 2020), NAAN encouraged the signatories to consider the lack of safeguards for children and vulnerable adult suspects. Version 2 of the JIIP (late April 2020) quickly introduced a requirement for police to carry out individual assessments of suitability and to secure the consent of the AA. However, research found that these safeguards were not sufficiently effective in preventing disadvantage to suspects (and thereby risks to the reliability of evidence). The signatories agreed and, from 17 May 2021, JIIP version 3 excluded all children and vulnerable people from remote legal representation.  This simplified the process for AAs, suspects and police.

With social restrictions lifted and vaccination levels high, JIIP version 4 (October 2021) introduced a presumption of in-person legal advice for all suspects. However, it included four exceptions for when remote representation could be used. Critically, it applied these exceptions to children and vulnerable adults. This meant that suspects for whom an AA was required could again be subjected to remote legal representation, and without even the imperfect safeguards. This conflicts with NAAN's understanding of the appropriate adult's duties and the rights and interests of children and mentally vulnerable people in criminal investigations. 

What guidance has NAAN given to appropriate adult schemes?

As has been the case throughout the Covid-19 pandemic, AAs should continue to attend police custody, subject to three requirements:

  1. Detentions/procedures are necessary (cannot be delayed or alternatives used); and 
  2. Appropriate PPE is provided to AAs by police whenever it is needed; and
  3. The custody environment is being run in a safe manner. 

After careful consideration, NAAN does not feel able to advise AAs to attend interviews in which legal representation is to be provided remotely. We appreciate that this presents challenges for other professions. We have therefore published a detailed rationale on this page (see below). However, in summary the rationale includes that: 

  • The duty of appropriate adults is to safeguard a person's interests, rights, entitlements and welfare
  • The available evidence indicates that remote legal representation is not in in the interests of children and vulnerable adults
  • The available evidence indicates significant risks to the reliability of evidence obtained in such circumstances
  • The available evidence indicates that suspects and AAs can feel pressured into accepting remote legal representation in order to reduce detention times
  • The available evidence indicates that consent from suspects and AAs may not always be informed consent
  • There is credible legal advice indicating that the JIIP may be unlawful in effectively amending PACE
  • There is credible legal advice indicating that, depending on the facts of the case, remote legal representation may breach Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights
  • There is credible legal advice that consent to a remote interview based on the JIIP does not constitute a valid waiver of rights
  • NAAN is not a signatory to the JIIP, it is not guidance for appropriate adults and appropriate adults are not bound by it. Where there is an apparent conflict between guidance and relevant legislation and statutory codes of practice, guidance should not be followed
  • The Covid-19 pandemic is no longer the unknown risk that it was in March 2020
  • AA attendance cannot replace the attendance of a legal advisor. 
  • Remote attendance by lawyers is not consistent with the national PPE guidance from the NPCC (police custody is either safe for all or for none)
  • While delays caused by the need to find a lawyer to attend are regrettable, they should be solved without pressure being placed on suspects and/or AAs late in a detention episode (e.g. by early consideration on the mode of legal representation).

And with specific regard to the exceptions introduced by JIIP version 4: 

  • It is illogical to apply remote representation where a a child or vulnerable person is (a) suspected of a serious offence and (b) is unwell with Covid, because in these circumstances their risk/vulnerabilty is even higher than normal
  • Similarly, it is illogical to apply remote representaiton where solicitors and legal representatives have Covid-19, because the risks of remote are compounded by sickness - an alternative can be arranged   
  • Where there are concerns about compliance with the JIIP more widely (e.g. hygience measures in custody, failure to consider alternatives to interview) the logical solution is for those measures to be taken.
  • The exception for non-Covid health reasons is inappropriate in a document that goes beyond PACE on the explicit basis that it is emergency Covid-19 guidance. 

NAAN appreciates that this does not relieve the operational challenges faced by police or lawyers. However, our position is that solutions should not be at the expense of the most vulnerable suspects and the interests of justice.

Appropriate adults are of course not controlled by NAAN and can face unforeseen circumstances. When performing their role, they must ultimately act according to their own judgement. If, in a particular circumstance, they conclude that it is necessary to support remote legal representation to safeguard a person's interest, they may do so. However, this should not include the circumstance of 'Hobson's choice' whereby in practice remote is the only thing being offered without significant delays. An appropriate adult who chooses to attend an interview with remote legal representation is strongly advised to record that the interview is proceeding despite the requirements of PACE Code C, the JIIP, NAAN guidance, and the consequent risks for all involved. In so doing, they should be aware that legal risks may arise for the suspect, because of their decision to enable the interview, that cannot be ameliorated at a later date. 


Detail

A. Purpose

B. Background

C. The legal status of the JIIP and remote legal advice

D. Legal representation for children and vulnerable adults

E. Role of the appropriate adult

F. Health and safety

G. NAAN’s interpretation and guidance

H. Resources

I. References

A. Purpose

  1. This statement explains NAAN’s rationale for its guidance for appropriate adults in relation to legal advice for children and vulnerable people in the context of Covid-19. It was first published in response to JIIP version 3 (May 2021), and updated in response to version 4 (October 2021).

B. Background

The response to Covid-19

  1. In March 2020, Covid-19 created unprecedented circumstances in police custody. Law firms were concerned about the health risks to their staff and about the financial risks to their businesses. The prospect of mass non-attendance at police stations meant police and prosecutors faced being unable to conduct interviews with suspects – something they consider to be an investigatory tool of critical importance.
  2. The Joint Interim Interview Protocol (JIIP) was agreed in March 2020 by the National Police Chiefs Council (NPCC), Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), Law Society (LS), the Criminal Law Solicitors’ Association (CLSA) and the London Criminal Courts Solicitors’ Association (LCCSA). These bodies remain the only signatories. No government department (e.g. Home Office, Ministry of Justice) is a signatory to the JIIP. Amended versions of the JIIP were published in April 2020 (version 2), May 2021 (version 3) and October (version 4).
  3. The JIIP describes itself as “guidance to assist investigators and prosecutors in deciding whether suspects should be interviewed as part of a police investigation during the Covid-19 pandemic”. In line with separate CPS guidance on charging during the pandemic, the JIIP provides a framework to reduce the number of interviews to the greatest reasonable extent. Notably, although national volumes briefly dropped significantly at the start of the pandemic, policing appears to have quickly returned to ‘business as usual’ levels.
  4. However, the JIIP also had a wider effect. It introduced the concept of virtual legal representation for people who are being interviewed in relation to an alleged offence. It encouraged defence solicitors and legal representatives to appear in interviews by video wherever possible (e.g. Zoom) or audio only (e.g. telephone) link rather than attending the police station.
  5. Organised appropriate adult (AA) schemes provide AAs where family and friends are not available or willing to support a child or mentally vulnerable adult. Many AAs are local community volunteers. Appropriate adults (parental or organised) were not party to the original development of the JIIP and are not signed or been invited to sign it. AA schemes have continued to attend police custody throughout the Covid-19 pandemic.

Legal aid and police station advice and assistance

  1. The Legal Aid Agency’s (LAA) Standard Crime Contract 2017 states that, ““Police Station Advice and Assistance” means Advice and Assistance given either by Police Station attendance or by Police Station Telephone Advice under section 13 of the Act”[1].
  2. Police station attendance attracts a fixed fee which varies geographically from £126.58 in Blackpool to £274.66 in Heathrow, with an average value of £165.15 (at June 2021). The Standard Crime Contract states that the fee covers “all work done on the Matter relating to Police Station attendance, including time spent advising the Client, travelling to and from the Police Station and waiting in relation to initial and subsequent visits to the Police Station. It also includes all letters and telephone calls and other work done outside the Police Station”. It is contractually defined as being claimable for matters “where at least one Police Station attendance has been given”. Higher fees are claimable in ‘exceptional’ cases, where profit costs, travel and waiting are more than three times the value of the police station fixed fee (if calculated using set hourly rates).
  3. In contrast, the telephone advice fee, is a much lower rate of £28.70 in London or £27.60 elsewhere (at June 2021). The Standard Crime Contract defines it as “the fee payable for all telephone calls for a Matter advising the Client in custody for which the Matter does not also include attendance at the Police Station.”
  4. The Law Society has repeatedly indicated its concern over the level of remuneration for criminal legal aid work, stating that, “Not only has there been no cost of living increase in criminal legal aid rates since the 1990s, but there was an 8.75% cut to fees in 2014”.[i] While it has not been possible to confirm this objectively, law firms have stated that police station advice and assistance is a ‘loss leader’, leaving them dependent on Crown Court trials to recoup losses and achieve profitability.
  5. The LAA did not seek to alter its Standard Crime Contract with law firms during the Covid pandemic. Instead, it indicated that it would use its discretion to disapply normal contractual expectations, in line with the JIIP for as long as it was in operation. Specifically, the LAA allowed law firms who provided remote advice and assistance to claim the significantly higher police station attendance fee, rather than the telephone advice fee, despite not actually attending the police station. Thus, in this context, the use of remote had a significantly positive effect on the profitability and financial sustainability of law firms.
  6. In April-June 2020, at the start of the Covid pandemic, criminal law firms’ Crown Court income from legal aid fell by 41% on the previous year. In response, law firms put many of their staff on furlough on the basis that there was insufficient work available. In contrast, the workload of legal aid police station advice reduced by only 8% in this Q1 period.[ii] Although these data are not yet available for the following 12 months, data on Duty Solicitor Call Volumes indicate that workload had returned to normal levels by June 2020. With many staff being supported by furlough, the relatively high levels of demand and profitability of remotely delivered police station advice (paid at the attendance rate) has presented an attractive proposition to law firms concerned about the financial sustainability of their businesses. As com put it, “the protocol is a life line to self isolating reps who were facing financial ruin”.

C. The legal status of the JIIP and remote legal advice

  1. Signatories have stated that the JIIP is not a legal document. It does not replace or supersede The Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 or its statutory Codes of Practice, or any other legislation or statutory code. The JIIP refers to itself as “guidance” to police. NAAN is not a signatory and, in any case, AAs are not bound by the JIIP. 
  2. The charity Fair Trials has published legal advice from a QC (senior barrister) that (amongst other issues) concludes that the JIIP (in any version) is unlawful because in effect it changes PACE.
  3. The JIIP (versions 2, 3 and 4) states that, “The signatories to this Protocol accept that remote interviews by video and audio link are not within the current letter of the Code of Practice…”. The use of remote legal representation relies on the JIIP signatories’ view that “remote interviews by video and audio link… are within the spirit of recent amendments to criminal procedure, law and evidence in the Coronavirus Act 2020”. As they accept, this is simply a view on the spirit of the law – yet to be tested in the courts.
  4. In recent years, the PACE Act and its Codes of Practice have been amended to support the use of ‘live link’ for tightly defined purposes related to interviews and some other custody procedures. This includes where (a) a police officer attends remotely because the person is detained by another force, (b) interpretation is required (due to certain languages being hard to source locally) and (c) where a detention is being reviewed or extended. These amendments to PACE Codes have been subject to policy development, stakeholder engagement and (under PACE 1984 s.67) consultation, and parliamentary approval. No such process has taken place in relation to live link for the purpose of legal advice. The PACE Act and Codes have continued to be the relevant legal framework.
  5. However, the right to assistance and representation by a lawyer at the investigatory stage is a fundamental right under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights, reinforced through and case law[iii] and domestic statute[iv]. In a briefing to legal professionals, the policestationreps.com website stated one problem with the JIIP was “Human Rights (ECHR) - It is quite tricky to give advice over a video link. It is hard to properly represent a client in interview without actually being there and damn near impossible by phone. Were an officer to make threatening gestures to a client off camera it would go unchallenged. A detainee would be well within their rights to refuse interview on the grounds he had not had access to legal advice in person. The ECHR position is well tested by the courts. Remote attendance is not sufficient in law as it could breach article 6 right to legal assistance. A defendant can sue the individual purporting to represent him”. The same article raised a number of other concerns, including security/confidentiality and ethics, stating that “Representation at the police station is a vital part of our criminal justice system. Ethically the client must always come first. Yet we are giving wider society precedence over legal rights”.
  6. The Home Office considered seeking a temporary amendment to PACE Code C to support the JIIP. However, following consideration, stakeholder engagement and a three-week public consultation (which was, in effect, a consultation on the JIIP as much as the Code), the Home Office decided not to amend PACE Code C, citing “significant issues”.
  7. The existence of JIIP is dependent on the agreement of all signatory parties. The NPCC has indicated that it believes that custody is now safe, and it would like to rescind the JIIP as soon as is possible. However, the legal profession indicated that it remains concerned about the health and financial impacts of a return to normal.

D. Legal representation for children and vulnerable adults

In law

  1. In relation to all suspects, PACE Code C:
    1. provides that a person may nominate a solicitor known to them, select a solicitor from a list, or use the duty solicitor scheme[v].
    2. provides that a person may at any time consult and communicate privately with a solicitor, whether in person, in writing or by telephone.[vi]
    3. provides that if a solicitor arrives at the station to see a particular person, that person must, unless Annex B applies, be so informed whether or not they are being interviewed and asked if they would like to see the solicitor. This applies even if the detainee has declined legal advice or, having requested it, subsequently agreed to be interviewed without receiving advice.
    4. provides that in certain specific and limited circumstances, the police can interview someone, who has requested legal advice but not yet received it. Notably, these provisions allow the interview without a legal advisor, not with a legal advisor providing representation via video or audio link, including where:
      • In relation to a person detained in connection with an indictable offences, there are reasonable grounds to believe that a delay would cause specified issues affecting justice, or the recovery of the proceeds of crime. [vii]
      • There are reasonable grounds to believe that a delay would cause specified issues affecting justice, or unreasonably delay the investigation (restriction on drawing adverse inferences from silence applies, requires authority from superintendent rank or above, there should be discussion with the legal advisor and an indication of how long police can wait before the solicitor’s arrival so there is an opportunity to make arrangements for someone else to provide legal advice)[viii]
      • a person’s preferred solicitor declines to attend and the person does not want a duty solicitor (no restriction on drawing adverse inferences from silence, requires authority from inspector rank or above)[ix]
      • a person changes their mind about wanting legal advice or about wanting a solicitor present at the interview and states that they no longer wish to speak to a solicitor (no restriction on drawing adverse inferences from silence; extensive safeguards apply including but not limited to: authority from inspector rank or above; if the solicitor arrives at the station before the interview is completed, the detainee will be so informed without delay and a break taken)[x].
  2. In relation to children and vulnerable people PACE Code C:
    1. notes that the Equality Act, in particular the public sector quality duty under s.149, applies to the application of the powers and procedures in the Code, which “must be used fairly, responsibly, with respect for the people to whom they apply and without unlawful discrimination” and that it is, “unlawful for police officers to discriminate against…any person on the grounds of the ‘protected characteristics’ of age [or] disability”.
    2. recognises that children and vulnerable persons “may, without knowing or wishing to do so, be particularly prone in certain circumstances to providing information that may be unreliable, misleading or self incriminating. Special care should always be taken when questioning such a person”.[xii]
    3. defines ‘vulnerable’ in terms of difficulties with the content, implications and significance of communication and the exercise of their rights[xiii]. The existence of the ‘vulnerable’ category is directly connected to ensuring that evidence obtained, in particular from interview, is reliable and therefore admissible in court.
    4. recognises that these elevated risks mean that children and vulnerable adults need to have in-person legal advice even where it is not offered to other suspects. Paragraph 6B, “explains the arrangements which enable detainees to obtain legal advice”. It explains that in certain circumstances, “Free legal advice will be limited to telephone advice provided by CDS Direct… unless one or more exceptions apply, in which case the DSCC should arrange for advice to be given by a solicitor at the police station, for example: the detainee needs an appropriate adult.”

Under the JIIP

Previous JIIP versions

  1. From version 1 (March 2020) the JIIP:
    1. included a provision that solicitors / legal representatives would attend some interviews “due to the serious nature of the case”
    2. included a provision that written statements under caution, developed with the benefit of legal advice, could be used in place of interviews
    3. did not include any provisions relating to children or vulnerable persons.
  2. Following representations by NAAN and others, JIIP version 2 (April 2020) included provisions intended as safeguards for these groups including:
    1. A requirement on police to assess a child or vulnerable person’s suitability for remote legal representation
    2. A requirement on police to secure the consent of both the child/vulnerable person and their appropriate adult before proceeding with remote legal representation. 
  3. Version 2 of the JIIP was active for around a year. However, the Not remotely fair? report, evidenced systemic issues with the JIIP and its implementation, with serious consequences for the integrity of the justice system, including failures by both police and solicitors and legal representatives to abide by the terms of the JIIP. This included:
    1. failure to minimise detentions
    2. failure to assess the suitability of individuals for remotely legal advice
    3. failure to fully inform suspects and appropriate adults
    4. failure to obtain informed consent from children and vulnerable adults
    5. failure to obtain informed consent from appropriate adults
    6. failure to conduct interviews with a legal advisor in attendance at the station when required by the JIIP
    7. wide variations between force areas in the percentage of interviews with children and vulnerable adults using in-person, video link and audio link legal representation
    8. placing of significant pressure on appropriate adults to consent to remote for the convenience of others, including where they and the suspect became victims of circumstance
    9. concerns about legal advisors having a conflict of interest with vulnerable clients, combined with a power imbalance
    10. suggestions that suspects may have been encouraged to accept remote advice
    11. children and vulnerable adults not understanding legal advice provided to them
    12. children and vulnerable adults not wishing to take up their right to free legal advice if lawyers were not interested in attending to support them.
  4. The signatories later published JIIP version 3 (May 2021). Additions included:
    1. “This Protocol does not apply to suspects who are children (under 18) or adults who are vulnerable”
    2. “The protocol remains in place for adult detainees and no longer applies to suspects who are either a child or young person (under 18), or adults who are vulnerable (using the vulnerable person definition in PACE Code C Paragraph 1.13(d) &1.4)”.
    3. “Therefore we take the view that they [interviews with a remote lawyer] are a fair, reasonable and proportionate option to be made available to an adult suspect with no vulnerabilities who has the benefit of legal advice and who having been fully informed and advised and consents to a remote interview.” (emphasis added).
    4. JIIP v3 was also accompanied by a flowchart which stated in red, “The protocol and this guidance applies to detainees who are 18 and over and not a Vulnerable Adult.”
  5. A letter from NPCC lead for custody ACC Nev Kemp to Chief Constables accompanied version 3 of the JIIP. The letter updated them on “our plans to start a phased withdrawal from the JIIP”. It stated that. “The first phase of withdrawal, aligned to step three of the government’s roadmap means that, the protocol will no longer apply to children and young persons (persons under 18), nor any vulnerable adult (as defined in PACE Code C paragraphs 1.13(d) and 1.4.). For these groups of vulnerable detainees, legal advice will return to pre-pandemic provision. In these cases detainees requesting legal advice will see a legal advisor in person for interview and will not have the option of remote advice as afforded under the protocol”.
  1. JIIP v4 was published in October 2021.The key changes from version 3 included:
    1. A starting presumption that legal representation in interviews will be in-person for all suspects (not just children and vulnerable adults)
    2. A set of expectations that police will have: applied enhanced cleaning and infection control measures, considered whether an interview is required now, considered a written statement, ensured all staff, officers and visitors will follow PPE guidance.
    3. A set of exceptions describing circumstances in which remote can be used with any suspect (including children and vulnerable adults), comprising where:
      1. A person detained in custody is Covid positive
      2. A named legal representative/firm or a duty solicitor is Covid positive or self-isolating
      3. Some other “exceptional reason” applies that makes it “not practical, possible or desirable”
      4. The police are unable to meet the expectations (in 27(b)) above.

With confirmed or suspected Covid-19

  1. On 7th June 2021, the NPCC write to all Heads of Custody and Chief Officers regarding JIIP v3. It stated:
    1. “The main change to the protocol, was that the provision to allow remote legal advice was no longer available for detainees who are children, or adults who are vulnerable”.
    2. “When considering the method of legal advice used, we must act with fairness to the detainee while also maintaining safety. Therefore, the signatories to the protocol have agreed that in cases where a detainee is confirmed as Covid positive, or is strongly believed to be Covid positive (for example, they display Covid symptoms but cannot be tested or refused to be tested) then the use of remote legal advice remains available for these detainees under JIIP version 3”.
  2. The NPCC confirmed to NAAN that in their view:
    1. The letter follows a meeting of the signatories and thus reflects a new agreement between them, intended to be effective immediately.
    2. This is intended to apply to “all detainees including children and vulnerable adults”.
    3. However, there is no intention to amend the JIIP.
    4. This is intended to apply to a tiny number of detainees being “those in custody on suspicion of a serious offence and an interview is required”. It is very rare to have a confirmed Covid detainee; lateral flow tests are not in use and a PCR tests take more than 24 hours to complete.
    5. Current PPE guidance requires police to treat all suspects as having Covid-19. Current PPE is adequate for all. ‘Strongly believed’ is seen by police as a high bar and is unlikely to be met by (for example) having a cough alone.
    6. If the child or vulnerable adult does not consent, the legal advisor should attend.
    7. The appropriate adult is a “key party to this discussion” and “if there are concerns then the AA will raise these and effectively ‘not consent’” but since there is no intention to amend the JIIP or return to version 3, there is “no explicit request to gain and secure the AA consent”. Any decision would be discussed by all relevant parties (detainee, legal rep, AA) and agreed by the custody officer about how to proceed.
    8. This does not apply to other communicable diseases – only Covid-19.

JIIP version 4 (current)

  1. In JIIP version 4, the signatories made explicit that remote can be used with children and vulnerable adults with suspected Covid-19, in addition to three other exceptions. 

E. Role of the appropriate adult

  1. The role of the appropriate adult in relation to a child or vulnerable adult is defined as follows.
  2. The Crime and Disorder Act 1998 s.38 provides that it is the statutory duty of each local authority to secure the provision of appropriate adults “to safeguard the interests of children and young persons detained or questioned by police officers”.
  3. PACE Code C 1.7A states that, “The role of the appropriate adult is to safeguard the rights, entitlements and welfare of juveniles and vulnerable persons…to whom the provisions of this and any other Code of Practice apply. For this reason, the appropriate adult is expected, amongst other things, to:
    • support, advise and assist them when, in accordance with this Code or any other Code of Practice, they are given or asked to provide information or participate in any procedure;
    • observe whether the police are acting properly and fairly to respect their rights and entitlements, and inform an officer of the rank of inspector or above if they consider that they are not;
    • assist them to communicate with the police whilst respecting their right to say nothing unless they want to as set out in the terms of the caution
    • help them to understand their rights and ensure that those rights are protected and respected.”
  4. Appropriate adults have specific role in ensuring the Article 6 right to access legal assistance, given the specific risks that children and vulnerable adults often waive this right without a full understanding of its significance and implications:
    1. PACE Code C 6.5A states that “…the appropriate adult has the right to ask for a solicitor to attend if this would be in the best interests of the person and must be so informed. In this case, action to secure the provision of advice if so requested by the appropriate adult shall be taken without delay in the same way as when requested by the person”.
    2. PACE Code C 3.19 states that: “If the detainee, or appropriate adult on the detainee’s behalf, asks for a solicitor to be called to give legal advice, the provisions of section 6 apply”.
    3. PACE Code C Annex G 4 states that, “If the appropriate adult, having been informed of the right to legal advice, considers legal advice should be taken, the provisions of section 6 apply as if the vulnerable person had requested access to legal advice”. 

6. Health and safety

  1. The Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 sets out a range of duties, including[xiv]:
    1. It shall be the duty of every employer to ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, the health, safety and welfare at work of all his employees (e.g. organisations providing legal advisors or AAs) (s.2)
    2. It shall be the duty of each person who has, to any extent, control of premises … to take such measures as it is reasonable for a person in his position to take to ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, that the premises… is or are safe and without risks to health (e.g. police forces) (s.4)
    3. shall be the duty of every employee while at work—to take reasonable care for the health and safety of himself and of other persons who may be affected by his acts or omissions at work; and as regards any duty or requirement imposed on his employer…to co-operate with him… (e.g. police, legal advisors and AAs) (s.7).
  2. The NPCC published extensive national COVID-19 PPE Operational Guidance. This has been amended throughout the Covid-19 pandemic and is currently at version 10. It states that in developing the guidance, “A specialist PPE guidance review group comprising of Public Health England (PHE), Health and Safety Executive (HSE), Defence Science Technology Laboratory (DSTL), Staff Associations, Police Health & Safety Advisors and senior Police leads is involved at every stage”. It also states that it “takes into account the most recent SAGE review of the National infection Prevention Control (IPC) plan, in light of the new more transmissible variants that are now present in our communities”. On this basis, AA schemes have operated according to expectations set by this guidance.
  3. The PPE guidance contains a section dedicated to operating within custody. In turn, this contains sub-sections for ‘custody staff’ and ‘visitors to custody and detainees (appropriate adults and legal representatives)’. The PPE guidance:
  4. Advises police staff that “Everyone you have contact with should be treated as though they are COVID positive”.
  5. States that, “for all duties undertaken in non-staff areas, including biometrics, searching etc” staff should wear an IIR mask, nitrile gloves, goggles and an apron. Custody staff are advised to “Ensure cells are cleaned between use and ask interviewing officers to clean down desks, chairs and contact points they use”.
  6. Includes a section on suspect interviews. It states, “Ensure your interview is socially distanced or other control measures are in place, such as protective screens. Due to the nature of custody interview rooms wear an IIR Fluid Repellent Surgical mask and Nitrile gloves. Note some PPE may hinder communication, however you need to remain safe. You should consider the need for apron and goggles. Require the interviewee to cover their face (where possible) with a IIR mask.”
  7. States that, “Those visiting custody need to cover their mouth and nose [and] should be offered an IIR Fluid Repellent Surgical mask”. They should consider wearing nitrile gloves, apron and googles. “Visitors and detainees should be encouraged to frequently wash their hands with soap and water, or use an alcohol based hand sanitiser” and “must be reminded of the need for social distancing, and encouraged to obey the 2m rule [although] some detainees may need to be kept under close escort which may mean this is not possible. Ensure you are wearing the correct PPE”.

G. NAAN’s interpretation and guidance

Our understanding of the law

  1. On the basis that the signatories have made clear that the JIIP is not a legal document, it is logical that, to the extent that it conflicts with the PACE Act, Codes or other relevant legislation and case law, the JIIP should be disregarded. In JIIP v3, the signatories have, in any case, explicitly excluded children and vulnerable adults. They also stated that, “The signatories to this Protocol accept that remote interviews by video and audio link are not within the current letter of the Code of Practice…”. On that basis, our guidance to appropriate adults must be based upon our understanding of the law.
  2. Our best interpretation is that:
    1. When supporting a person known or strongly believed to have Covid-19, by complying with the NPCC COVID-19 PPE Operational Guidance is complied with, police forces, AA schemes, and AAs are ensuring, so far as is reasonably practicable, the health, safety and welfare of the AA, the police, the person being supported, and any other visitor to custody.
    2. It is the legal responsibility of the appropriate adult to safeguard the rights, entitlements, welfare (and at least in the case of children the ‘interests’) of a child or vulnerable adult. This includes taking an active role to ensure they are treated properly and fairly, and that their rights and entitlements are protected and respected.
    3. Whether cases proceed to court or are dealt with via an out of court disposal, the appropriate adult’s role is to provide assurance that fair trial rights have been respected at the investigatory stage, processes have been carried out as set out by Parliament in PACE, and evidence has been gained in a manner likely to render it reliable and admissible to courts.
    4. There is no duty on appropriate adults to balance the interests of a child or vulnerable adults with the health or financial interests of legal advisors, nor the health interests of the general public. Doing so could be a failure to discharge their duty to that person.
    5. There is no specific provision in law for remote legal advice in PACE, unlike other uses of ‘live link’.
    6. There is a high level of risk that remote legal advice contravenes the law, in particular the Article 6 right to legal assistance, and in relation to children and vulnerable adults the Equality Act 2010.
    7. To “attend” the police station (or voluntary interview) means to be present physically - not to appear on a screen or to be available by telephone. This appears obvious both in statutory (Code C 6.5A, 6B) and contractual terms (Standard Criminal Contract). There may be debates to come and Parliament may in future legislate on the issue of remote legal advice. However, the meaning of “attend” is currently clear in terms of its operational application.
    8. Where a child or vulnerable person has indicated they do not want legal advice, it would be lawful for an appropriate adult, acting in the child or vulnerable person’s best interests under PACE Code C 6.5A, to nominate one or more specific providers of criminal legal assistance on the basis that they are willing to attend in person to advise a child or vulnerable adult, whereas other firms are not (see para 31(c) above). In normal times we would advise caution in relation to general use of this power by organised AA schemes, due to the risk of the perception or inappropriate commercial relationships between AAs and law firms. However, this guidance does not undermine what the Codes say. Many AAs are parent or family members, and they may well have a preferred solicitor – perhaps one known to have specialist skills in relation to children or a particular condition. This would always be an appropriate use of 6.5A in our view. In terms of contractual law, we do not believe that this is contrary to any of the terms in the Standard Criminal Contract. In operational terms, this would be treated as be a request for an ‘own solicitor’.
    9. It would be lawful for a child or vulnerable person to be provided with a list of local providers of criminal legal assistance, as described in PACE Code C 6.6(c). Particularly in an area where one or more duty firms have a current policy of non-attendance at the police station, this could be a list of firms who have indicated that they are willing to attend for children and vulnerable people.
    10. A child or vulnerable person is entitled to switch from a duty solicitor who is not willing to attend to another firm which is willing to attend. An appropriate adult could assist a child or vulnerable adult in requesting this change, based on their duty to provide assistance under PACE Code C 1.7A. Any attempt to prevent such as change, such as by the operation of the DSCC, could be presented for a judicial review.

In cases which do not fall within the exceptions in JIIP v4 

  1. Under JIIP v3, the vast majority of police and law firms appeared to be complying with the need for legal advisors to attend the police station for interviews of children and vulnerable adults. The removal of remote legal advice for children and vulnerable adults solved the challenges associated with: (a) police officers having to assess the suitability of individuals for remote advice without appropriate training or tools, (b) legal advisors having to deal with conflict of interest with clients, and (c) appropriate adults having to decide whether or not to consent to remote advice. To the extent that the JIIP v3 was applied in practice, the expectations on appropriate adults were extremely clear. Their role is as normal. They should continue to attend the police station when requested, with the shortest possible delay and provide support throughout all procedures to enable compliance with PACE, in line with the National Standards.
  2. Under JIIP v4, where cases do not fall under the exceptions there is no conflict with our understanding of suspect’s legal rights in relation to legal advice and representation, or the role of the appropriate adult. The guidance for AAs is therefore to perform their role as usual, ensuring that remote legal represenation is not applied to children or vulnerable adults.  

In cases which fall within the exceptions in JIIP v4 

  1. In placing children and vulnerable adults outside of JIIP v3, but then re-applying the use of remote legal advice in JIIP v4, the signatories place the most vulnerable suspects back at a level of legal risk that they had determined was unacceptably great and without even the system of safeguards (e.g. assessment of suitability, appropriate adult consent) that were present in JIIP v2.
  2. In practice, the NPCC have indicated such a situation should occur extremely rarely. Police should explore all possible options (release with no further action, under investigation or on bail to return; a written statement; or charge without interview). If a person’s welfare is seriously at risk, an assessment of their fitness for detention or a transfer to hospital may be appropriate.

The four exceptions

  1. However, depsite the low volumes, there are still particular issues with each of the four exceptions:
    1. It is illogical to apply remote representation where a a child or vulnerable person is (a) suspected of a serious offence and (b) is unwell with Covid, because in these circumstances their risk/vulnerabilty is even higher than normal (when remote is not allowed)
    2. Similarly, it is illogical to apply remote representation where solicitors and legal representatives have Covid-19, because the risks of remote are compounded by sickness - an alternative can be arranged   
    3. Where there are concerns about compliance with the JIIP more widely (e.g. hygience measures in custody, failure to consider alternatives to interview) the logical solution is for those measures to be taken.
    4. The exception for non-Covid health reasons is inappropriate in a document that goes beyond PACE on the explicit basis that it is emergency Covid-19 guidance. 

Remote representation under the JIIP in principle

  1. Furthermore, in principle, the exceptions in JIIP v4 conflict with our understanding of suspect’s legal rights in relation to legal advice and representation, and the role of the appropriate adult. It is therefore necessary to defer to PACE and its Codes of Practice.
  2. Based on our understanding of the above, it is difficult to see how appropriate adults could support remote legal representation in principle, since they would have to:
    1. Place the JIIP above the law (Remote legal advice is not consistent with PACE, especially in relation to suspects for whom an AA is required. It is unclear that remote legal advice is consistent with a person’s rights under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights)
    2. Be able to justify how PPE provisions make the interview ‘safe’ for them, the suspect and the police, but not for the legal advisor (The NPCC PPE measures require all suspects to be treated as if they have Covid-19. Appropriate adults, legal advisors and police officers have been advised by the NPCC the PPE measures are sufficient to protect them from Covid-19. If this is the case, the legal advisor should attend. However, if it is necessary for the police to provide the special measure of remote in order to protect the health of a legal advisor, then PPE measures are by definition considered insufficient and it is not safe for the appropriate adult to attend.)
    3. Be able to justify how in supporting an interview with remote legal advice, they were acting purely to safeguard the interests, rights, entitlements and welfare of the child or vulnerable person, not balancing these against other factors (It is the legal duty of appropriate adults to safeguard the interests and rights of a child or vulnerable adults. It would be a breach of this duty to seek to balance it with the interests of a law firm or the general public, or the police)
    4. Have recorded in the interview and custody records both how such an arrangement fails to safeguard the rights and interests of the child or vulnerable adult and why considering this they have chosen to enable the interview with their presence.

Options

  1. For the vast majority of cases, the police have a range of options that are PACE compliant, including release under investigation, bail and charging without an interview.
  2. Written statements under caution increased in use due to their inclusion in the JIIP. However, they are also explicitly included in PACE Code C so remain an option even though children and vulnerable people are excluded from JIIP v3. A child or vulnerable person must not be asked to provide or sign a written statement under caution in the absence of the appropriate adult (PACE Code C 11.15).
  3. If having fully explored all options, police feel it is necessary to undertake an interview, appropriate adults should continue to decline to attend the interview unless a legal advisor attends in person. The resultant situation for the police cannot factor into the decision making of the trained appropriate adult, any more than it would be of a parental AA.
  4. If no legal advisor is found to attend and all other options had genuinely been exhausted (including a interview without a solicitor present where allowed under Code C 6.6) the police would likely proceed with an interview with a remote legal advisor either having secured an alternative appropriate adult who was less informed or with no appropriate adult. Both of these options are deeply concerning for the suspect, appropriate adults and police – while not being of their making. Appropriate adults are of course not controlled by NAAN and can face unforeseen circumstances. When performing their role, they must ultimately act according to their own judgement. An appropriate adult who chooses to attend an interview with remote legal representation is strongly advised to record that the interview is proceeding despite the requirements of PACE Code C, the JIIP, NAAN guidance, and the consequent risks for all involved. In so doing, they should be aware that legal risks may arise for the suspect, because of their decision to enable the interview, that cannot be ameliorated at a later date. 
  5. The key element is for appropriate adults to be called, and to attend, as soon as is practicable in detention, not to wait until later in the process when an interivew is imminent. If police propose that remote legal advice is used in an interview, appropriate adults should ask for a request is made to the DSCC for a legal advisor to attend in person as early as possible in the detention.
  6. If the first legal advisor declines to attend the police station, and instead offers remote representation, the police can request an alternative legal advisor via the DSCC, repeating this until a legal advisor is found that is willing to attend the police station. 
  7. If no duty solicitor can be found that is willing to attend the police station, the appropriate adult may ensure that the person is provided with a list of local legal advisors who have indicated that they are willing to attend for a child or vulnerable adult. This list can be compiled at the time by the appropriate adult or in advance by their scheme. If the person declines legal advice, the appropriate adult act on their responsibility under Code C 6.5A and request legal advice from a firm on the list.
  8. In the unlikely event that no lawyers in a particular area are willing to attend the police station for a child or vulnerable adult, the appropriate adult should still not attend an interview with a remote legal representatives.

Urgent interviews

  1. In the most serious cases, where police do not feel that any of these approaches are possible, PACE Code C 6.6. provides a limited option for urgent interviews without a legal advisor present where this is necessary in the interests of justice. If this paragraph applies in the circumstances and its safeguards are followed, appropriate adults should attend the interview as it is PACE compliant.
  2. It may seem counterintuitive to an appropriate adult to attend an interview with no legal advisor but to refuse to attend where a legal advisor assists remotely. It is likely that the argument will be put to the appropriate adult that something is better than nothing, and that it is in the interests of the suspect. However, the latter is not compliant with PACE where the former is compliant with PACE and is tightly defined with a range of safeguards. The former leaves the appropriate adult liable to accusations that they failed to safeguard rights, where the latter does not. If the interview is urgent, PACE Code C 11.18 enables police to conduct an interview of a child or vulnerable person without the appropriate adult being present in specified and limited circumstances.

Detention times, PACE clock and "change of mind"

  1. The appropriate adult should remain alert to the risk that a child or vulnerable person could have a ‘change of mind’ regarding legal advice due to pressure from other parties or simply being a victim of circumstance. It is hard to imagine a scenario in which such a change of mind occurs in these circumstances without the person being a victim of circumstance. This can occur where the person decides not to have a legal advisor present in interview because none wishes to attend, or it has taken a very long period of time to find one that is willing to attend. This is a highly risky situation for a child or vulnerable adult as, subject to Code C 6.6.(d) being followed, there is no restriction on adverse inferences from silence. The best solution is to avoid this situation arising by arriving at the police station as soon as possible – giving time for any legal advice issues to be tackled early. If it does arise, it is not clear to what extent the appropriate adults right to request legal advice (Code C 6.5A) is applicable here, particularly if it has already been used. However, AAs should seek a private consultation with the child or vulnerable adult to discuss their decision and ensure they consider the long-term risks and significance of their decision. The appropriate adult should ensure that the safeguards in 6.6(d) are followed and that the officer considering the authorisation is fully informed of any concerns that the change of mind was the result of pressure from individuals or circumstance. If the interview proceeds despite the AA’s concerns, they should ensure their concerns are recorded on the custody record and interview recording. Alternatively, if they feel that the interview is not proceeding in compliance with the PACE Codes, they can use their inherent right to refuse to attend the interview.
  2. The appropriate adult should ensure that they are not coerced into attending an interview with a remote lawyer on the basis that the person has been detained for an extended period. While the appropriate adult must safeguard a person’s welfare, this is in addition to and not balanced against their rights. In some circumstances appropriate adults must take steps to protect rights which do not make them popular with the person they are supporting – if only in the short term. If a person’s welfare is seriously at risk due to the length of detention, an assessment of their fitness for detention is the appropriate route.
  3. The appropriate adult should ensure that they are not coerced into attending an interview with a remote lawyer on the basis that the PACE clock is running out. Custody time limits and the expediency of the investigation are a matter for the police alone. The law defines custody limits and there are measures police can take to extend limits if appropriate. It may be obvious to an appropriate adult that delay is not within the control of police (e.g. multiple lawyers have refused to attend the police station despite police requesting advice as soon as was practicable on detention). However, it is not within the appropriate adult role to enable investigators to carry out interviews that are not compliant with PACE. It is within the appropriate adult’s role to make representations to ensure that a person is not detained for longer than necessary.

Reporting

  1. Appropriate adults should report any use of remote legal representation to their scheme leader immediately. Appropriate adult scheme leaders should report such information to NAAN. NAAN will raise reports with the Home Office, NPCC and Law Society.  

8. Resources

9. References 

[1] Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012, Section 13 (Advice and assistance for individuals in custody) 

[i] https://www.lawsociety.org.uk/campaigns/consultation-responses/independent-criminal-legal-aid-review-law-society-response

[ii] https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/legal-aid-statistics-quarterly-april-to-june-2020/legal-aid-statistics-england-and-wales-bulletin-april-to-june-2020

[iii] https://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/FS_Police_arrest_ENG.pdf

[iv] PACE 1984 s.58 (access to legal advice), reflected in Code C s. 6 and the notice of rights and entitlements.

[v] PACE Code C 6.6(c)

[vi] PACE Code C 6.1

[vii] PACE Code C Annex B

[viii] PACE Code C 6.6(b), 6A

[ix] PACE Code C 6.6(c)(iii)

[x] PACE Code C 6.6(d)

[xi] PACE Code C 1.0

[xii] PACE Code C 11C

[xiii] PACE Code C 1.13(d)

[xiv] https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1974/37/part/I/crossheading/general-duties

[xv] NAAN National Standards 5.3 (Response times) https://www.appropriateadult.org.uk/national-standards

Continue reading